1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

I Tried the 9mm and Liked It...Feeling Guilty :)

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by rockhound758, Feb 28, 2010.

  1. rockhound758

    rockhound758 Well-Known Member


    Okay, I'm a long-time .45, .357, .44 and .40 guy...never had much use for the 9mm and will STILL keep my XDM .40 as my home defense gun (with Ranger ammo)...BUT I recently got my CCW and have been thinking through weapons. Was planning on carrying a 4" SS Champion (shoots straight as anything) but it's kind of heavy, so I rented the G19 and G23 today. Years ago I owned a G22 but traded it in for another weapon.

    So, long story short, I shot the G23 just fine today, but the G19 was like magic. Very fast follow up shots, VERY accurate rapid fire, and while I don't mind the G23's recoil, the 9 is noticeably less and seems quicker for follow up. I'm sure with training the G23 would be equally great, but seeing as how I don't yet have a 9mm, AND thinking I might want to have one since ammo is readily available, I'm probably gonna pick one up.

    That said, I'm feeling a bit guilty about liking the 9mm...is there some place here on THR I can go for absolution? :)

    Have a good night all!
  2. wgp

    wgp Well-Known Member

    None needed. Go with it. I usually carry a .45 but have no issues with a 9, .38+P or even .380 when that fits better. No question that I shoot the 9 better than the .45 (could be my customized HiPower is just that much more accurate). Pick good ammo and enjoy the 9.
  3. duns

    duns Well-Known Member

    OP, if you mean the 9mm is considered puny, then my view on it is there is no clear winner in the caliber wars. Although i don't have much hands on experience with guns as yet, I've done a lot of reading on the subject. I think the increased shootability of the 9mm may more than compensate for any lack of ballistic efficiency compared with a caliber that begins with a 4 (or the 357 caliber). And you get to pack more rounds and the ammo is cheaper.
  4. Boats

    Boats member

    I'm primarily a .45ACP and .357 Magnum shooter myself, but I love the 9mm on its own terms too.

    I'd never voluntarily rely upon it in FMJ, but with modern construction hollow points it holds its own.
  5. W.E.G.

    W.E.G. Well-Known Member

  6. rha600

    rha600 Well-Known Member

    Try shooting a PX4. I shot a rented G19 and the recoil from my PX4 is slightly less. At least it seems like it.
  7. bds

    bds Well-Known Member

    I have Lone Wolf 40-9 conversion barrels in my G22/G27 to shoot 9mm for practice and I love it!

    Cheaper to shoot and I can load them fairly hot to give me a good comparable light 40S&W load for practice.

    If it puts a grin/smile on your face, keep on shooting! :D
  8. Tilos

    Tilos Well-Known Member

    I know the feeling

    This is the 2nd time today for me.
    This is hard but I'm gonna do it:eek:

    My name is Tilos.. and I have, shoot, and like a 9mm gun:eek:
    I feel better already:uhoh:

    I bought a 9mm drop in barrel and G19 Mag for my Glock 23.
    I have shot more than 3000 rounds through it and it would take me at least 30 minutes to even FIND the stock 40 barrel for it!

    Buy the G23 and for the price of a barrel and mag ($130+/-) have a G19 to shoot.
    You can't beat two guns in one.

  9. NG VI

    NG VI Well-Known Member

    My next couple of pistols will be 9mm, having been a longtime .40 fanboy I am beginning to switch tracks a bit, I don't believe the 9mm is weak, or worse as a defense cartridge than .40 or .45, because as cool as it is to have a cartridge that begins in .4. it's cooler to have significantly cheaper ammunition, lower recoil, higher capacity in the same size frame, all of those are great things.

    And it works fine on people provided you don't load it like a jackass or according to NJ state law.
  10. JohnKSa

    JohnKSa Well-Known Member

    Yup, if shooting a 9mm weren't an advantage there wouldn't be power factor limits or penalties for lower power factors in practical shooting disciplines.
    Can you train with the G23 until one day you're as good with the G21 as you are with the G19 today? Yes. But when you've reached that level of proficiency the G19 will still recoil less and let you follow up faster. You can't beat physics.
  11. Gunfighter123

    Gunfighter123 Well-Known Member

    Sorry but I don't understand --- no hollow points in NJ ???
  12. NG VI

    NG VI Well-Known Member

    Not for carry, I don't know, their laws about it are all screwy, hollow points are ok for range use, and possibly home defense, it's a gray area, but not out and about I think.

    I don't know, someone who knows more about it will come along. All I know is that it's all mixed up.
  13. Gunfighter123

    Gunfighter123 Well-Known Member

    And I thought we had it bad in Illinois !!!!
  14. Colton White

    Colton White Well-Known Member

    Some lady in NJ was fined 1000 per hollow point she had in her gun...
    good thing it was only a J frame haha
  15. nwilliams

    nwilliams Well-Known Member

    I'm a huge fan of the 9mm, always have been.

    I don't care what anyone says, the 9mm has proved its worth many times over. I love the round for target shooting because it's relatively cheap and plentiful and I'm not afraid to carry 9mm as a defensive round. My primary ccw is a 9mm S&W 3914.
  16. Fremmer

    Fremmer Well-Known Member

    I'm glad you feel guilty. Now go buy a Smith & Wesson 952 so that I'll feel less guilty about wanting one of 'em. :D
  17. Jed Carter

    Jed Carter Well-Known Member

    I started with a S&W 39-2, then .357 revolvers and then .40 S&W SIG , finally the M1911 in .45 acp. Now I shoot in IDPA and IPSC matches, Glock G34 soft shooting, and laser straight is my choice. My former carry weapon was a SIG P232 .380, now I use a CZ 75D PCR 9mm ( traded a S&W 59 for it). I have rekindled the old friendship with the 9mm, so much in fact I'm now looking at a 1911 chambered for 9mm. Get the G19, I almost did, would have if the PCR had not jumped into my hand, but I am done buying CZ, (have the best), not finished buying Glock.
  18. dom1104

    dom1104 Well-Known Member

    I think this typifies the .45 guys, the .45 is such a part of their persona they feel guilty if they switch :)

    Like a guy who works at Ford who cant admit he enjoyed driving his buddies Toyota.

    Either way, welcome to the world of cheap WWB ammo. :)
  19. 19-3Ben

    19-3Ben Well-Known Member

    Exactly. They're illegal there.
  20. lilidiot

    lilidiot member

    Just another stupid Liberal Gun Grabbing Mindset State. Please don't tell them that we won a few wars and now are still using FMJ in our military to kill people!

Share This Page