If You Could Only Have One Carry Piece For the Great Outdoors, Woods, Mountains,etc.What Would it Be

IJ1981

Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2019
Messages
463
Location
Coral Terrace, Florida
A follow up on the SD thread. Thank you, Lots of possibilities here. Rifle,Shotgun, extreme handgun.

Add a second or third alternative if you wish, and tell us your reasoning if you will, THR.:D

I was remiss to add this is for North America situations only.
 
Last edited:
I think I need more information? Am I just rambling around through the woods, or am I hunting something?

For just wandering around through the woods in the south eastern US, which is where I live, I would be OK with just my 9mm CCW (Sig P365 or Glock 43X). Not too worried about grizzly bears or sasquatch down here. The shotgun idea above is very versatile, but I wouldn't want to be stuck lugging a long arm.
 
I think I need more information? Am I just rambling around through the woods, or am I hunting something?

For just wandering around through the woods in the south eastern US, which is where I live, I would be OK with just my 9mm CCW (Sig P365 or Glock 43X). Not too worried about grizzly bears or sasquatch down here. The shotgun idea above is very versatile, but I wouldn't want to be stuck lugging a long arm.

You could be rambling or running for your life! You want the do all gun that keeps you alive
 
My #1 pick is my Marlin Guide Gun .45/70.
A powerful piece especially with the great 400 grain Randy Garrett loads ,it will take down Polar Bear, Grizzlies ,Moose,Elk and anything else in NA that gets in its way.

As a alternative the Mossburg Persuader Shotgun interchangeable barrels, a deadly piece.

Last the Browning .338. It is a great cartridge and will nullify all of the NA terrain.

.
 
One gun for everything!

It would have to be shotgun with a variety of loads. My top pick is my 870 Express with a 21" turkey barrel. That barrel takes interchangeable tubes making it quite versatile with any 2 3/4" or 3" shell. It's a bit of a handicap for long range wing shooting, but fine for most upland game.

Even with just the bead is accurate enough with slugs for any big game out to 50-75 yards. I do have another 20" rifle sighted barrel that stretches slug accuracy to 100+ yards. But that barrel is cylinder choked and a poor choice for regular shotshells.
DSCF0513.JPG

If it has to be a rifle, then a bolt action 308. This Winchester. At close range it will kill anything a 45-70 will kill with less drama. And still shoots flat and accurate enough to kill most of them at 400-500 yards.

ayla road trip 2 143.JPG
 
No mountains where I live - just woods & farm fields.
My preferred outdoor carry firearm is a 4" .357 magnum revolver. Spring, Summer, & Fall the first two rounds are snake shot, the remaining rounds are 158 grain SWC. A few years ago, I came upon 3 bedded down large coyotes about 9 AM in the morning. There are a few timber rattlers in this area and the creek has some water moccasins. Only other danger would be coming across a druggie cooking meth or watering his hidden weed crop.
 
Assuming I’m pulling from my safe, I think a 12 gauge pump is hard to beat for versatility. Mine is a Mossberg 500. Unless I was out with the specific goal of hunting, it would be wearing the 18.5 inch cylinder barrel with a front bead. Pocketful of slugs, buck, and #4 bird shot and I’m pretty well covered.

If I can take a handgun, too, 4-inch GP 100 in .357 magnum. Cylinder would be loaded with full power hard cast loads, but a few light loads might come along in the day pack.
 
Last edited:
One outdoors gun?

Since most of the time I'm here on the east coast, or possibly in the midwest (the furthest west I routinely go is Minnesota), I'm looking at black bear and occasionally moose as my worst possibilities. Until I go camping further west, I'll go with a medium framed .357mag. A K-frame or L-frame (or GP100) will even handle the bear strength loads with reasonable recoil, while still being quite manageable for carry. I don't hunt so walking around with a shotgun or rifle in my hands just wouldn't be very handy as I go about my business while camping, walking or kayaking in the woods, and slung over my shoulder, it would likely be much slower to get it on target than drawing a revolver from a strong side holster.

When I take a summer for a cross country camping trip (I'm a teacher and off summers, or will be when I stop teaching summer school), I may change that up to at least a .41mag and more likely a .44mag in a 4" N-frame. My .45LC 625MG is doable, but a little large for all day carry if grizzlies aren't a possibility and standard .45LC may be a bit under powered for grizzly (though when outdoors when someplace where very large black bears are possible, I sometimes take it). In grizzly country, if I went .45LC I'd probably want a Ruger for the "Ruger only" loads from Underwood or Buffalo Bore.
 
East of the Mississippi, probably an 870 Wingmaster with somewhere between an 18 and 24 inch barrel with rifle or ghost ring sights. Pretty much a police configuration. I figure it can take care of just about anything that would come my way, big or small. Don't have to worry about a scope getting knocked off either. If extra barrels are allowed I'd have a 28 inch barrel, 18 inch barrel, and a 24 inch rifled barrel. A selection of chokes would be a plus.

West of the river, I'm thinking any lighter weight bolt gun in .308 Win. I'd scope it with the most rugged scope I could afford with a low end magnification of ~2 and high end of ~10. A Ruger SFAR would be a serious consideration if ARs weren't so awkward to carry in the field.
 
Last edited:
"One gun to rule them all" threads are dominated by shotguns because of their versatility and ignore that no one gun does all things well (but the humble shotgun does more things adequately).

The shotgun is also a lot heavier, and its ammo is a lot heavier, than most people are gonna want to tote for a long distance while bumming around in the woods.

If the purpose of the gun is general self defense while in the woods, I still would contend that your usual CCW is the best choice. Even in the woods, the greatest predator of humans is other humans.

Just my 2 cents, others will have differenet opinions.
 
Last edited:
index.php


If I can only have one, I want it to be concealable, easy to carry, and shootable with one hand. Which leaves me with a .357 Magnum or this G20. I'll take the G20.
 
Savage 24…this one is .22 WMR over 20 gauge, but I’ve been looking for a .30-30 / 20 gauge or a .22 WMR / .410…

I refinished this (Duracoat and Danish Oil/polyurethane). It doesn’t have the classic blued look any longer, but it is more protected.

I keep a small pocketknife, flashlight, firestarter, compass, whistle, tin of .22 WMR, and 3 20 gauge shells in the stock pouch. (Along with an Allen wrench to remove the scope mount…just in case…I need to get a replacement rear sight for this).

The sling is one I wove from paracord…again, just in case.

I really enjoy taking this to the nearby state forest.

(I realize that the “just in case” is most likely not going to happen, but it was fun kitting it out.

upload_2023-6-19_20-0-16.jpeg
 
Mine would probably be a 4” 629 or 66. Handguns would be much more comfortable and easier to carry around.

Although a rifle or shotgun would bring a lot more to the fight as far as power and distance.
 
I have had my CCW for 55 years and have carried many different pistols. Now I carry a Colt huntsman or Woodsman .22LR in a belt holster and a Charter Arms .44 Special in my back pocket. All the black bears that I have come across have run so the .44 has been unnecessary. For the first 20 years or so it was a Ruger Security Six .357 2 1/2 inch. After that a model 57 .41 Mag Mountain Gun for about the next 20 years.
 
Back
Top