What makes you think that?
I should have said "many".
Have you tried all different types of holsters and all carry methods? I suggest you try all types of holsters that's on the market before making that claim.
The claim is "for all-day concealed carry,
I find a single-column semi auto much more comfortable than a revolver, and than a service-sized double column semiauto, for that matter."
I have tried a number of handguns and a number of holsters, but of course my opinion is personal.
I carry an EZ9, OWB, all day. It is light and thin and easy to conceal. It is cnduciive to drawing quickly., it has a good trigger pull, good sights, and capacity on the low end of my preference. The type of OWB holster that I use spreads the load--loads, in all axes--which contributes to comfort.
Many here have chosen different defensive pistols--the P365, for example--and different holsters. Fine. One carries a Glock. except when dress requirements lead him to carry a six-shot .32 J-Frame.
Then change how you dress.
Do you think I should wear a long topcoat all day? How would
you dress to conceal an L-Frame revolver with a five inch barrel?
NO!
What does Colt have to do with anything?
Colt now sells a six shot snub with an excellent trigger pull, which is what I wanted.
Based on what? Your imagination?
A rather simple, basic human factors engineering analysis. Or, one could try using common sense.
A semiauto doesn't have to be unloaded.
What????
I am trying to rationally discuss pros and cons for different purposes as I see them, allowing for differences in people's needs and abilities, etc.. I have undertaken enough defensive training to know what has worked best for
me in the drills. You seem intent upon arguing for the sake of argument. I would never suggest that anyone change how one dresses unless I thought it helpful.
I know many people sho carry revolvers for defense, but the preponderance of informed opinion today is that there are better choices.
How is your quest for training going?
Let's remember that there is a lot more to handguns than concealed carry and defensive shooting. In my opinion, it is in
those areas where the revolver really shines.
I would suggest that we concentrate our discussion on those.