medicine calf said:
These Guide Gun setups are nice. I can understand the utility of the 45-70 for bear and pig hunting, but for what other purposes are shooters using these rifles?
Understand that the loads and grain sizes vary greatly, and the 1895G can handle all of them, though I suggest you run a dry patch through the barrel before going hunting/to the range/whatever if you are going to shoot super hot and heavy loads. The gun can take these loads. Over and over and over. They will continue to take these loads when your grandkids are born if the firearm is well-kept and if your handloading skills are adequate (I have no such skills, but will be getting into it to save $$$$).
Greg Bell said:
And the GG package gives you the ability to chose from relaitvly modest Remington trapdoor loads to 500 grain solids capable of taking Rancors.
Rancors. It wouldn't surprise me. 2 or 3 well-placed shots with the load Greg mentioned would be far more efficient than killing a Rancor by way of a heavy gate. It's funny he alluded to Return of the Jedi because ever since I touched a lever gun, I found it to be "an elegant weapon of a more civilized age"... flashback to episode IV.
As for the Guide gun, its versatility in handling all manner of loads is virtually unmatched, and for the general size and handiness of the weapon its power is
completely unmatched. I personally find chopping the barrel one of those en vogue things people feel the urge to do with their guide guns. Sure, they make them a little handier, but I prefer the extra length because frankly the ballistic curve of the .45-70 needs all the help it can get. Your regular stainless guide gun has an overall length of ~36.5 inches, which I find to be more than sufficiently handy. Furthermore, you will have a slightly longer sight radius. The late Jeff Cooper advocated a maximum barrel length of 39 inches for the rifle to be considered handy, and I'm not willing to part with mine just to chop the barrel. If I get a shorter lever gun, it will be in .45LC. Now that's a handy general-purpose rifle, but the bottom line is that I find my Marlin to be handy enough. Not bad for the most versatile big-bore cartridge ever made (IMHO).
I have handled a special edition of this gun which was priced about $100 over the standard 1895G with about a 16.25 barrel and tritium sights - the long red post through the front and green tritium canisters in the rear. Seemed like a waste, since tritium open sights in broad daylight are grossly inferior to a ghost ring aperture. Any person that has experience with ghost rings knows that they only need to keep their eye on the front sight, it is a faster system with equal or better accuracy, and not at all unmanageable in low light. Greg's idea of a glow-in-the-dark front post seems like a great cheap mod. I am going to give it a shot.