New Springfield GI 1911 - Range Report

Status
Not open for further replies.

gbelleh

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Messages
1,747
Location
Kansas
Having owned and sold two 1911s, I started getting the itch for a 1911 again. So, I went out and got a new Springfield GI, just the plain parkerized model. The safety was a little stiff, but the slide to frame fit seemed tight and it looked good.

I took it to the range for a quick shoot with several different types of factory new ammo. It was totally stock and I only used the factory magazine.

The gun failed to go fully into battery 3 or 4 times with Blazer brass FMJ, always the 1st or second round out of the factory mag. The same problem occured later with American Eagle FMJ. It fed and fired very well with WWB FMJ, WWB Personal Defense, and Blazer aluminum cased ammo. No stovepipes or jams besides the few failures to go into battery. A tap on the slide always chambered the round.

Extraction was a bit inconsistent. Most were back and to the right, but several flew straight up in the air and hit the gun or my hands on the way down.

Here's the main problem. After about 150 rounds, the stiff safety became immovable. Stuck in the safe position. On closer inspection, the plunger tube had worked loose. The safety could still be operated with some manipulation of the tube, but I packed it up and went home. Overall, I was pleased with the trigger and accuracy of the pistol.

I'll be taking this gun back to the dealer so it can be sent back to Springfield for some special attention. Hopefully it will come back all better. I had very good results with a micro compact I sent back to Springfield a few years ago. I'll update this once it comes back from Springfield. This could be a very fun range gun if these few problems are fixed.
 
Instead of going to all the effort and hassle of sending it back to Springfield Armory, you could have a local gunsmith, (if you do have one nearby), restake the plunger tube. The thumb safety most likely just needs a file lightly applied in the right spot to free it up, another task any decent 1911 mechanic could do in about five minutes.

Just a thought.
 
BB gives a good suggestion, but on a new gun with a lifetime warranty, I think I'd ship it back to Springfield. Tell Deb at Springfield you want a couple of extra magazines for your trouble.

I'm sorry to hear this story, it's one among several. QC might be slipping at Geneseo.
 
I don't really know any good local gunsmiths, and I figure why pay someone to do what Springfield will do for free? I bought this gun knowing it might need to go back, so it's not that big a deal as long as it's fixed when it returns.
 
sorry to hear that but i am glad that you were honest and told us about it in your range report. i would definetly send it back to springfield, and not spend a die out of my own pocket.
 
Extraction was a bit inconsistent. Most were back and to the right, but several flew straight up in the air and hit the gun or my hands on the way down.
:D :D :D that would be funny to watch. that reminds me of the time i was at the range and a shell casing from the lane next to me flew over the divider, hit the ceiling, and landed in my shirt pocket.:eek:
 
I have one, too (SA GI).

I had to file just a hair off one side of the firing pin stop to get it to function.

Got about 1500 rounds through it so far, no other problems.

Mine is a "knocking around in the boonies don't mind if it gets dinged up" type gun.

PS, almost forgot, mine throws brass all over the place too. It is a bit disconcerting to be lining up next shot and have brass DOINK! off the top of my head.
 
Lubricate heavily! New 1911 need a little help in that department. I've bought brand new MilSpec and GI's to convert to bullseye wadcutter. My gunsmith ask that I run 500rounds min before turning in the pistol for custom work. By habit, I drop oil into the rails and a lot around the barrel bushing...works great all the time...gets a little messy when I overdo things:rolleyes:
 
Well, my Springfield GI arrived at my dealer 10 days after he sent it out to Springfield. On inspection, the plunger tube was solidly back in place, the safety was no longer overly stiff and the slide seemed to operate more smoothly than before.

I took it to the range today and ran a few magazines of every kind of .45 ammo I had through it. No malfunctions. The safety worked as it should.

I'm very pleased with Springfield's customer service, turnaround time, and their repair work.
 
Me Too

I'm so sorry that you did not have a very pleasant experience with your new
Springfield Armory WW-II G.I. replica~! I would have to agree 'bout asking
Deb for a little compensation for your troubles; and I feel most certain that
the fine folk's at Springfield Armory will take care of your problematic firearm.
 
The SA 1911A1 Mil-Spec I bought 2-3 years ago had a problem with very erratic ejection. I replaced the stock extractor with a Wilson Combat billet steel (more "tunable") extractor and that problem went away.

Once you know how to tune the extractor on a 1911 it makes a huge difference! Now my brass lands in a pile small enough to pick up every one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top