Put Down That Hacksaw....

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dave McCracken

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
13,936
Location
MD.
And back away from that shotgun....

I had known the rookie Correctional Officer three days or so during the range training portion of his in-service training. I wanted to kick his butt so bad my knuckles were itching.It was nothing he had done on the range but something he had brought.

It was a mid grade LC Smith 12 gauge. Nice wood, good metal, what there was left of it. He had bobbed the barrels to about 20 inches to use as a "House Gun". I informed him that he had, by dint of ardous effort, taken a shotgun worth a couple grand perhaps and left it worth a couple hundred. Then I stomped off maddernheck....


The lure of short barrelled shotguns is strong medicine. The strongest is the SxS guns we refer to as Coach Guns, Alley Cleaners,Sawed Offs,etc. Their simple lines and obvious lethality translate into high Cool Factor.

And, even with the 2 shot limitations, they make good defensive shotguns for folks that might have trouble with the more complicated repeaters.

Civilian defense incidents are over in a shot or two for the most part, not the Battle for Hue.

The Coach style guns are also great fun, as any CAS shooter can tell you.

So are various short barrelled repeaters, including Remington's Special Field models and most "Riot" repeating shotguns.

So, folks have bobbed the barrels on whatever shotguns were handy. Sometimes this works. Sometimes, as in the incident above, it's a serious mistake.

I've made that mistake. Both when setting up my first "Serious" 870 and later when I "Lupara'd" a Ranger marked Stevens 311.

On the first, if I had spent maybe $40 more than what it cost to have that barrel shortened and a front sight installed on a slug barrel, I'd still have that barrel in the shape it was when Pop gave it to me.

In the case of the Lupara, I should have just opened the chokes and lived with the 28" of barrels. It may not have swung as fast but chances are it would have swung better.

BTW, the OA length of a SxS with 28" barrels runs about what a riot barrelled repeater like an 870 does. Just how short do we need/want our shotguns to be?

Chances are Uncle Zeb's 32" barreled Goose double does not have a sleek 26" barreled grouse wand in it struggling to get out.

So, you ask, what should we do to get nice short barrelled shotguns if cutting the barrels is Blasphemy to The Shotgun Gods?.

Buy the more common new guns from Russia and Turkey, or the less expensive Spanish makers of yesteryear. One poster here has a 10 gauge American Arms 10 gauge that fits the bill, though I doubt he uses it for skeet or CAS.

For repeaters, but an extra barrel or another shotgun.

And a customized single shot from H&R or NEF makes an outstanding walking around shotgun.

Please do not cut down our lethal art, or our own heritage.....
 
Dave,
Thank you again!

WE harp about this, and even mention the fact no choke is left, and the legal matters and ...and...

Some get "it" , some don't want "it" and some will never understand "it".

Steve
 
Right, Steve. The fact that some questions get asked means they won't get the answer. Some truths ARE self evident.

Some downsides of shortening are....

Besides removing chokes, shortening a double means removing the barrel regulation too. Some doubles will not print both patterns on the same 4X4' sheet afterwards.

More blast and flash. At night, this can be critical.

Shortening many barrels means a higher POI.
 
WWBD?*

Seems to me that Mr. Brister had an anecdote or two about bobbing barrels.

Personally, I'm not against any modification which will enhance the usability of a particular gun. A case in point is the Model 12 I use for grouse hunting. It originally sported a long(ish) full-choke barrel. After a little work, it now has a roughly 24" barrel that throws a more open pattern. It is far more handy and effective now.

That being said... I wouldn't make such a permanent modification to a gun which had any collector value remaining. When I picked up the Model 12 mentioned above, it came off the used rack with little remaining finish (and this was from an obvious refinish as well), a chunk of kindling removed from the toe of the stock, and numerous dings and scratches on the barrel and receiver.

You also need to look at rarity. Cut down the barrel on an 870 Express and I wouldn't bat an eye. Do the same thing on a mint Sweet Sixteen and that's worthy of corporal punishment. Do it on a Model 21 and you should be put on a small island with no provisions except for a pistol with a single shot.

One more comment... I think a lot of this can come from people simply not knowing what they have. Folks who aren't into guns can look at an old SxS and think "That's not worth much, and I don't hunt, so this might be fun." while they rummage through the toolbox for the hacksaw. It's one reason why I keep an up-to-date list of our firearms, complete with a description of what it is, what it cost, what it's worth, and a brief paragraph or two describing any family connection or historical data. That way, if I die, my wife or kids won't be left trying to figure out what they've got. They will also know that I'll come back and haunt them if they cut down the barrel of the 1922 Model 12 which was purchased new by my grandfather.

* What Would Brister Do
 
His only crime was not knowing he had something valuable. Short barreled shotguns are awesome for exactly the purpose he had in mind. As soon as my house sale closes in a few weeks, I am planning to send off a Form 1 to make my saiga 12 into a 14 incher.
 
Thanks Dave.

I have an acquaintance who was thinking of doing the same thing to "grampa's old shotgun". I asked him if I could see it first:

16 ga LeFevre Nitro Express!

I told him I would personally make sure he could never use it again if he touched it with a hacksaw. :)

(The gun is for sale now, but I don't need another gauge.)
 
Well I have a question. Where would one obtain a reasonably priced short barrel?

I'm about to chop a 28" 870. I would much rather have both barrels, but from what I've found, I could buy a whole 'nuther shotgun for the same money.
 
I only had it done once and found out it ain't worth it. I found a decent shape Stevens 67 with a modified choked barrel and proceeded to make a defender out of it. I paid $110 for the shotty and forked over $50 to have the barrel cut to 20" and have the front sight replaced and $20 for touch up cold bluing in the barrel to cover up some scratches and marred areas.

I thought that it was cool to have a riot gun made...the feeling wore off quickly when I started gearing up for hunting and I realized that I took a good starter gun for someone else and destroyed it. :banghead: I disliked myself after I had done that to someone's potential bird gun. :fire: I ended up selling off the shotgun to a friend for a mere $75 who used it as a defensive shotgun in his camper.

It plain ain't worth it...just buy a dedicated pump with a shorter barrel or a sxs coach gun for defensive needs! :cuss:
 
Being Blunt.

Folks do not think. Folks are in a hurry going nowhere. Life is about them, and all that matters is immediate self gratification.

Folks want so desperatly to fit in, be a part of something, they latch onto ideas and material things to be - accepted.

Ask questions and listen. This ain't rocket science. There is nothing in the world wrong with being brutally honest with yourself and admitting you do not know something.

Ask in a civil, respectfull manner. When one is reading something, or hears something, I was taught to ask questions - NOT questioning the person - Instead asking for clarifications so I could understand at my level.

When answering - be respectful of the person asking. Just like kneeling down to a child to get on their level. Nobody appreciates being talked down to, especially if they are sincere in asking.

Now I was also taught, to ask for references, so I could read more and learn. This also allows me the ability to get more than one perspective and viewpoint.

Some things just "are". The sky is up. Water is wet. Ice is cold and Fire is hot.

Some things must be learned by investigation , research and asking good questions.

Brister's Book - answers a LOT of the questions asked on forums. A lot of folks, even out of the Continental US have ordered this book and read it.

Do you know, how many nasty PMs I have gotten from suggesting that book?
Lots. I mean even threatned with bodily harm nasty PMs.

It is "my fault" a person cut down a barrel, after I and others suggested they not. Suggested how serious the legal is about too short, and for gosh sakes measure Thrice, cut once. It is my fault, this barrel was cut too short and gunsmith destroyed it proper and legal and finding a new barrel is going to be a real chore. He wanted to test a military sword on me...if you get my drift.

Hacksaws and shortening barrels are just one example of a larger disease.

Folks do not have the social interaction skills , and Internet exposes more of this problem to a wider audience with anon folks participating in real time such as Internet is.

Just cutting to the chase here folks.

--

New guns with two barrels [combo's] are smart buys.

Shotgunners are different folks from those that have a shotgun and cannot shoot.

Just how much difference is 18.5" from 26" ? It is 7 1/2" is how much. Does this seven and a half inches make a differece? Well okay, if frying bacon in the nude, yeah having your tallywhacker get grease splatterd ...
...Then again most guys seem to manage to get around a bathroom stall, approach a urinal , and not "bump" into everything with thier tallywhackers.

Hey, cannot hit targets? Learn the correct basic fundamentals of shooting with what fits and shoot closer. Still one has to practice hitting a toilet taking a leak. You hit the urinal because you are closer, missing the toilet ain't got nothing to do with how long your tallywhacker is, it has to do with correct basic fundamentals , and focus on target (hitting the toilet) and not focusing on hardware.

-
Need a shorter barrel for heavy cover hunting? Pay attention and after duck season, you find a barrel 28" long someone busted firing with mud in it, buy it right. Have a qualified person like Briley, or Colonial check it out, and have it cut to 20" and threaded for chokes.
Now not only are you legal, but you have versatily of choke for HD, turkey, woodcock ...from 5 thousandths of restriction to 40 thousanths if need.


I have folks I am working with via PM that asked honest sincere questions. They care not one whit about black and tactical, some have serious physical limits, and they cannot shoot a UltimateWhammerJammer with JawJattering loads. Breaking a neck means being paralyzed! Doctors orders on recoil limits.

I hope folks never go through these life matters that physically limits them...but...it would be wise to consider one at anytime could be in a car wreck, and that kewl factor gun, with short barrel, firing heavy loads, and curb feelers and fuzzy dice weighing 12 #s is NOT going to be allowed by a doctor, permanent damage can come from doing so.

Heart bypass patients are limited to 10 pound weight lift limits. Other surgeries have weight lift limits too. Hey, shooting a shotgun after my emergency appendectomy , was not on my priority list for a bit...

Hey, I know (counts in head) 3 folks that detached retinas with short barrel guns with heavy loads, and 3 that had wrist surgery from using PGO shotguns.

6 folks, never met in person...Gun forum folks that PM'd me to tell me and apologize to me for being ugly to me when I begged them not to do these modificatons.

<steps off soapbox>


Steve
 
I nearly made that mistake, too

I picked up an older Stevens 311 for that very purpose...but then thanks to the kind folks here on THR (especially OkieCruffler) I had a change of heart -- a quick reply to my serial number question pointed out that my particular specimen was from 1949.

It'll probably never be 'collectable' (or even valuable) but taking a hacksaw to it immediately smacked of sacrilege. Happy Ending: It has become my favorite trap gun...and I picked up a NIB Stoeger coach gun for 'sawed off' duties.

Thanks again THR!
 
I'm about to chop a 28" 870. I would much rather have both barrels, but from what I've found, I could buy a whole 'nuther shotgun for the same money.

www.budsgunshop.com has them for a shade under $100. Ask around at the local gun shops and gunsmiths, many times they'll have a used bbl that's close to what you're looking for.
 
Don't see why everyone is obcessed with having uber-short barrels. My planned HD gun is a 26" Rem 1100, which will pull double duty as a Skeet and Trickshooting gun. I am fully confidant in my ability to handle a 26" gun inside my house. The extra barrel length will also afford me the ability to use a larger magazine extention, which means more ammo in the gun. The more barrel I have, the better I can control my shot, the less risk stray buck pellets pose to my kids, my neighbors, or my stuff.

But to be fair, I have thought about how awesome it would be to cut an O/U down to right before the end of the foregrip. Of course, the BATF has thought about what it could do with the $200 it would cost for me to legally make a shotgun that short. And I am throughly convinced I can spend that $200 better than Uncle Sam. So that remains a pipe (literally) dream.
 
sm,
Holy crap!! Someone forgot their meds today!! :eek: :eek: :eek:

That's just the way he communicates.

Some folks find it rambling and hard to read.
Others find it poetry.

As for me, I find it both.

The world's a funny place.
THR can be funnier.

Like this post.

Which is now over, thank you very much.
It's been fun to type this way, but I'll leave it to the old pro.

Goodbye.

And Godspeed.

.



Torpid

.
 
A smith I used to know cut down the barrels on a Greener 10 gauge. One barrel had split at the muzzle when some lout tried a steel load in a shotgun made when the Queen of England was named Victoria rather than Elizabeth.

No loss there, but the LeFever mentioned in a recent thread here deserved better. Every LeFever I've handled or shot pointed like my finger.

Larry, the last Nitro Express I saw had some rust, needed a wood restoration and went for $800,IIRC.

The NE was an Ithaca model, acquired after they bought the assets of one of the companies Uncle Dan sold.

Last Syracuse LeFever I noted in an ad was $3500.

And if someone wants to lop off an Express barrel, I shan't snivel. Last time I did, it worked out OK even if the muzzle is off center.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top