Comment on Comments - Robbed at Gunpoint
Excellent thread you triggered, newbie4help. Thanks!
Some comments on comments:
1. Tossing an armed keyfob is a great idea that I have not heard of before. Thanks, Chieftain. It is really two distractions, the flight of the fob in a direction calculated to divert the BG, and the blare of your car horn from another. How to deploy this dual distraction effectively is worth its own thread. Tossing to the same side of you as your car is might be advisable, otherwise the BG's gun is going to sweep you and your companion as he scans both distractions. By causing BG to turn in only one direction to scan two distractions, you gain more time to counterattack or escape. Way to trash his OODA loop!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OODA_Loop
2. The fake money clip distraction is often mentioned, but I don't recall a single report of its effective (or failed) use. Even a couple of successful instances does not mean that the strategy is sufficiently dependable. If reliable stats exist on the subject, they would be of interest.
3. Armedandsafe's comment # 27 also brings up something new. I usually carry my Glock 26 or KelTec P9 in my right cargo pants pocket, which permits a natural 'wallet draw" (as long as I keep my facial expression appropriate).
4. "that being said...NEVER TURN AROUND! as a long time police trainer, guys dont ever give in unless you must (and since you [the OP] were unarmed i dont blame you.)"
So what do you propose to do in the specific circumstances, Janobles14?
5. "To quote Massad Ayoob, "Never draw on a drawn gun." I quote the James Bond's film title: "Never Say Never". Don't falsely limit options. I'd modify the advice to "Never draw on a drawn gun without an effective distraction and plan, OR the opportunity and ability to physically divert the BG's weapon and follow up effectively" (which most of us probably have not adequately trained to do).
6. Quote: "I don't think this was a case of not being "situationally aware" because 1) it's a parking lot - you expect to see cars and 2) we couldn't have seen them where they were parked." Unquote.
"No. It is mostly about being "situationally aware." The BGs will intentionally pick spots and conditions such as your parking lot scene to do their dirty deeds. As sm points out, you (and we) must pick up the signals of a threat early when it appears."
I have to disagree. One can be highly situationally aware, but the threat may exhibit NO "signals", instead being effectively concealed (by stealth, dissimulation, ambush, etc) until too late, as Joe Cool points out. The answer to this criticism usually amounts to "you should have anticipated anyway", as FCFC asserts; however, that argument is circular.
Situational Awareness is not a talisman any more than a gun is. SA just tilts the odds in your favor, like the gun does.
Provocative comments! No disrespect intended to anyone I disagree with. Lots of material for further discussion!