I have finally decided I am going to purchase a smith j-frame. I'm going back and forth between the 642 and the 442. I believe a prefer the looks of the 442, but I'm wandering about the finish. I have done some fairly extensive research on the finishes of the two, and have come up with conflicting stories. Some say the 642's finish holds up better, and others say the 442 does. What have you guys/gals experienced? I appreciate any input.