My $0.02 worth:
- Pound-for-pound, squirrels are the best game animal in North America. While not inherently difficult to bag, doing so involves all the best features of true hunting. A morning of stalking bushy-tails in the woods is, for my money, far more fun than sitting in a blind waiting for a whitetail to wander into view.
- Generally speaking, I prefer a .22 rifle for fox squirrels. By using calls I can usually get them to hold still long enough for a clean shot. This offers a decent challenge and the advantage of no potential for lead pellets in the meat.
- Greys/cats, on the other hand, tend to be more skittish and won't hold still for long, so I like a shotgun (20 or 12 ga.) w/#6 and a mod. choke for them. I've not had any problem with locating more greys after a shotgun blast, provided I hold still and wait a few minutes afterward.
- Squirrel tastes nothing like chicken. It's more reminiscent of turkey dark meat than any other domesticated food animal.
- If the weather is sufficiently cool that you can delay skinning your squirrels until you can get them someplace with clean water you'll be doing yourself a favor. Squirrel fur has the adhesive properties of Super Glue, and if it gets on the meat (and it will, especially during your first few attempts at cleaning them) it's a major pain in the arse to remove, which essentially requires that you pick it off one or two hairs at a time. Dunking the squirrel in water first (or hosing it down) mats the fur down and helps prevent it from coming loose and sticking to the meat when skinning.
- Here's the best tip I can give you, and one I doubt you'll hear from anyone else: My son (the real squirrel predator in the family) and I discovered that the greatest delicacy squirrels have to offer is their liver and, to a slightly lesser extent, heart. When cleaning your squirrels, locate these organs and save them in a platic baggie for later. When ready to cook them (we like them as an appetizer) rinse them in cold water, slice the hearts in half length-wise, and *lightly* dredge everything in some flour with a little of your favorite seasoning mixed in (we like a Cajun mix, but to each their own.) Melt some butter in a skillet over medium heat (I suppose you could use olive oil or some such if you're trying to avoid butter and margarine, though we've not tried that yet) and sauté the livers and hearts for about 1 minute on each side, or until golden brown. Remove to a paper towel to drain and immediately salt to taste. The results are magnificent. I detest beef liver, which is strong and bitter to my tastes...but squirrel livers have a delicate, soft flavor that is similar to goose and duck livers. Most types of heart are delicious, and squirrels' are no exception. Try this once and you'll thank me.