1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Wanting new slim 9mm

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by tackleberry45, Oct 15, 2013.

  1. tackleberry45

    tackleberry45 New Member

    OK, I know this is a rehash. I have large hands and wondering if anyone has shopped for a slim carry 9 and what the results were. I have a G26 now and I am trying to decide if it is worth the width reduction. Pistols like the XDS-9, Shield, Nano, CW9, LC9 and many others I am sure. Has anyone with large hands switched to one of these? Which one and why?
  2. jon86

    jon86 Member

    I'm trying to find one myself. I've owned a glock 27 and found it just too thick for IWB carry.

    I've shot a Kahr cw9, shield 9mm, and a Ruger LC9. I would still like to shoot a walther pps, XDS, and Bersa BP9CC. Out of the Kahr, the shield, and the ruger, I prefer how the Kahr shot. I was most accurate with it. The shield wasn't that far off.
  3. bigfatdave

    bigfatdave New Member

    My favorite carry-designed singlestack 9mm pistols are:

    Tied for 1st place:
    Walther PPS
    9mm officer size 1911 from Armscor

    Third place:
    Springfield XD(S)9

    Fourth place:
    KelTec pf9 (bonus points for .22lr conversion)

    ... and I have large hands (2xl gloves) but liked slim pistols to start with.
  4. foxmoor

    foxmoor New Member

    I made the same switch, as I found my G26 too wide for CCW carry. I went with a Kahr P9 Black Diamond with night sights and couldn't be happier.
  5. beeenbag

    beeenbag New Member

    I have a g26 and a nano, I have large hands but really like the little nano, I shoot it better than I did my kahr cm9. I can pocket carry the nano in jeans.
  6. MedWheeler

    MedWheeler Active Member

    My hands aren't huge, but my fingers are kind of long and thinner. Still, I can handle the harsh handling of the Kel-Tec PF9 just fine, and it is my EDC (I switched from a gun that was not only thicker-gripped, but shot a less-powerful round.)

    So, anything even marginally thicker, such as the LC9 or CW9, would simply be that much more pleasant.
  7. nevadabob

    nevadabob Member

    About 6 months ago I had my sights set on buying a 9mm Shield. I already have a M&P full size and was looking to purchase the Shield. Instead of the Shield, I left the LGS with a 9mm Bersa BP9CC. The grip and the trigger sold me. And for around $400, you won't go broke either. It has some good reviews.
  8. Teachu2

    Teachu2 New Member

    If at all possible, shoot before you buy.

    I have personal experience with three of your options mentioned.

    My EDC is a G26, and I have no issues carrying it. I am fast and accu7rate with it, and can shoot a couple hundred rounds thru it comfortably any day.

    My slim 9 is a Shield. Not as good with it as the G26, but still acceptable. It's my formal attire piece.

    I had a LC9. Accurate, but slooow and less than comfortable. Gives up too much just to be smaller. Trigger sucked. Sold it and made two people happy!

    If at all possible, shoot before you buy.
  9. Tomac

    Tomac New Member

    My experience mirrors that of Teachu2. I prefer to carry my P250 hybrid doublestack but a singlestack 9 is easier to carry & conceal.
    Tried the Kahr CM9 & CW9 and while surprisingly accurate for such small pistols, I needed a Hogue grip sleeve for shooting comfort.
    Tried a SIG P290RS (DAO like my P250) and while the grip is slim and doesn't fill my large hand comfortably like the bigger P250, I shoot it nearly as well and it carries/conceals much better w/o the need for a grip sleeve for comfortable shooting.
    Handle/shoot as many options as you can, I'm sure you'll find something that will fit your particular needs.
  10. Pilot

    Pilot Active Member

    I handled a S&W Shield 9MM yesterday at a LGS. I liked it a lot. It was slim, but still with a large enough grip to get a good hold. I also handled a Sig P938, and liked that also, but the grip was very short, and only allowed a two fingered hold. It was also more than $300 in cost over the Shield.
  11. ntg

    ntg Member

    Mine is a Shield 9mm. 938 are nice but too much $$$ for me. I like the feel of the Nano, but didn't ever warm up to funky slide release. Was set on PT709 for a while due to great trigger, but went S&W for better quality reputation.
  12. snooperman

    snooperman New Member

    I like the Walther PPS for IWB as well as my S&W 3913.
  13. Madcap_Magician

    Madcap_Magician New Member

    I actually bracketed your Glock 26... I find my M&P Shield to be more comfortable (if not really any more concealable) due to how thin it is. On the other end, I find the Glock 19 to not really be any less comfortable or too much harder to conceal in a good holster (TT Gunleather IWB) than the Glock 26. So those are my two...
  14. Mango88

    Mango88 Member

    I have rather large hands and find that the Walther PPS with the large grip insert fits me very well and if anyone else in the household wishes to shoot it, I simply snap in the small grip insert.
  15. ritepath

    ritepath Member

    I did 40 hours of research on the last toilet I bought. I'm somewhere in the 60 hour or more range on what single stack 9mm (in my budget range) so far I'm coming up Shield. I've still got more to go, the shield is a little heavy but covers most other bases I want. Gotta take a look at a g36 and bp9cc.

    I rarely carried my m&p 9c because it was just too thick. I traded it and now it's time for something beyond my LCP. A thin 9 or 45 should do for my purposes.
    Last edited: Oct 16, 2013
  16. Sergei Mosin

    Sergei Mosin Active Member

    When I think slim 9mm, I think Browning Hi Power, but maybe that's just me.
  17. browneu

    browneu New Member

    Browning BDM.
  18. jpruitt

    jpruitt New Member

    The Walther PPS is super slim and a joy to shoot. And you can get 6-, 7-, or 8-round magazines depending on how much grip you want.
  19. Pilot

    Pilot Active Member

    You know that isn't far fetched at all. The BDM was one if not THE slimest, full size, double stack 9MM's out there. I still prefer the Hi Power, however, but the BDM is an interesting piece.

    Another slim 9MM is the HK P7, but I got the impression the OP was looking for a newer, sub-compact, but I could be totally wrong.
  20. Orion8472

    Orion8472 New Member

    I'm still hoping that CZ will come out with a "thin Rami". Few guns fit my hand as well as a CZ and having one thin enough to be adequately concealable would be of extreme interest for me.

Share This Page