Oh dear... are we doing this again?
Well, I like these threads but I'm sure some members will be along later to tell us we is dumb for wasting our money and should go out and get a quality gun...
But for the record... why Milsurps?
1) Aesthetics: I like a gun with a lot of wood. Full stock, full handgaurd. Every Milsurp rifle is a unique creature because of the wood. If you are not a purist you can shop based on wood alone and refinish the rifle in many wonderful and delightful ways. If you leave the rifle in original finish you still have a handsome and rugged looking machine. I just like the way a wooden 20th (and late 19th) century firearm looks. The gawkiness of the early guns is gone and the plastic & metal look was still to come. I like older commercial guns too, but the surps are my favorite.
2) History: Doesn't matter to me if the gun was ever fired in anger. I couldn't care less. But holding and using an artifact of those eras just makes me happy. Dealing with the "in-progress" designs of some of the guns is fun too, where the bugs of that technology was not well worked out (hakim, SVT 40 etc.) and the compromises between ergonomics, accuracy and ruggedness. My only wish is that we mere peons could have access to the full-auto guns a bit more easily / affordably.
3) Education at the Range: It is a rare trip to the range where I do not have at least one other shooter ask me "What kind of rifle is that?" Opportunity to let someone know about a gun model that they would likely never see. I like chatting at the range while taking a break and they are good ice-breakers with people who also like chatting - and we both usually end up learning something. Kids are fun too, their eyes go big when they see and hear a surp on a range.
4) Cheap ammo: even with it approaching 30 cents a round it is still cheaper than the alternatives for centrefire. the only one I reload for is the K31, everything else eats ammo from the 50s to the 80s. Even with the rise in 8mm it is still 3 shots for a dollar.
5) Education for me: Darn I've learned a lot of obscure stuff because of this hobby. Reading internet, books and watching documentaries I've learned about the guns and the history.