Gordon
Member
Another vote for a .357 Max, that way the youngster could get used to gun in .38 spl, and try .357 158 grain HP and few .357 Max for final sight in. The progressive getting used to the gun will work well I promise. .357 Max is pretty loud and starts to recoil just a bit in a carbine BUT you have the option of it. .38 spl cheap practice loads can't be beat, the kid will love to shoot their gun ! A .357 mag 158 grain in a carbine is good for deer to 100 yards and the max get you another 50+ yards.