Thumper- it wasn't MWR that killed the clubs. It was clinton and the PC effort. Mostly clinton's policies though, the budget was cut and things were left to sink or swim. In the end they all sank since people didn't want to deal with MP's in the parking lot and the poor service/food of the clubs. His policy is the same reason the stables, theatre's, car care, and crafts centers have left most posts.
I only know the Army end of it. However, our clubs are now nothing that I would take anyone to. In the past I know that it was an honor to go to the O' Club, now they're usually pretty nasty and run down.