sixgunner455 wrote:
Flint - Would the snare have killed the little one eventually?
In this case...I believe it would have, but it depends heavily on the type of snare "lock" you use, how hard the animal pulls and IF the lock holds up and functions as intended.
There are "releasing" and "non-releasing" locks of various designs. Some function much better than others.
You can have a releasing type lock NOT release if it bends or the cable becomes kinked at the point of the lock.
The opposite is true as well, non-releasing locks can be bent or damaged such that they do "relax" when you don't want them to.
I rarely use snares because there is always the danger of catching Non-Target Animals. Although I am careful to set snares in very select spots AND take other measures to mitigate capture of NTA's...it can happen.
The use of the snares related in the story above was carefully calculated to catch only escaping (or possibly approaching hogs).
Snares (depending upon how they are set) catch and "kill" indiscriminately...so you need to know what you are doing and NOT be lazy about checking them or taking precautions.
But back to your question, yes in this case... the hog hit the snare on the run and also struggled vigorously when first caught.
The result was that the cable tightened enough to partially compress the trachea making it difficult for the hog to breathe IF it kept expending energy fighting.
Even with snares designed to kill the animal, many things come into play as to whether or not they actually do... and how humanely (read quickly) that happens. We can discuss that further if there any interest...
but in a separate thread.
With the snare type I use (and how I normally place them), I would say I run about 50/50...(finding the animal dead or alive).
I do use a lock designed to be non-relaxing...but that only means it holds at whatever point it is pulled to.
To me...of more importance is having a good "stop" on the cable end. You don't want a very alive (and mad) hog pop the stop off the cable and come get in your back pocket.
If someone wants to start a new thread discussing the use of snares as a tool, their effectiveness, tips, safety factors, techniques or ethics of their use, I will contribute what I can.
I have used snares to some effect...but don't use them much, nor do I use dogs very often...but both have their place.