Unpopular and underrated older bolt rifles and cartridges?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 28, 2002
Messages
3,476
Location
Baltimore
I have a vague desire to get a vintage bolt action hunting rifle for some various projects, and though it'd be cheap and easy to get a Stevens 200 in .223 or .308, I want something with more character, both in terms of design and of being chambered for an interesting cartridge I can handload. But optimally something not too expensive, not one of the high-demand classics.

For chambering, I'm looking for something between 6mm and .30 to keep reloading components affordable, and I'm inclined to lower recoil/power options rather than mag cartridges since this is mostly for target shooting and plinking, not really a hunting deal.

As examples, I considered the Savage 340 in .222 or Winchester 43 in .218 Bee, but 6mm is the minimum caliber for NRA Rifle Silhouette shooting, so gotta bump the diameter up a little bit.


Open to suggestions, what's a clunky/sleeper hunting rifle that's not high in demand and price, in some interesting chambering that's not carried at every Walmart?
 
Going back to the OP guidelines, I'd point out 8mm is over .30 cal., and Swedish Mauser's are presently a high demand classic.

Sounds like you're looking for something that was a sales flop at the time. Maybe something like a .244 Rem. or a cartridge that was superseded by other better performing cartridges, like a .300 Savage or 30-40.

Maybe one in a less expensive brand like Mossberg, Stevens, or Savage, or a house brand like Sears Ted Williams, or Montgomery Ward's old house brand.
 
In my experience, the 7x57 is an excellent hunting cartridge. It's usually refereed to as the 7mm Mauser. I prefer .275 Rigby :p
Another interesting (and purely American) cartridge is 300 Savage.
 
most underrated bolt action and cartridge out there in my opinion is the arisaka type 99, incredibly strong rifles that can be easily converted to more relevant calibers
 
A Savage Mod 170 pump 30-30 is not too expensive, same with the "Western Auto/Montgomery Wards lever and bolt guns. Mossberg bolt guns come to mind. JC Higgins FN Mausers are still nice, same with Santa Barbara Mausers (sporterized) and Santa Fe Arms. And yes, the Arisakas are soild rifles, but even more butt ugly than a Savage! ha.
 
There are still some model 30s selling reasonably.The last I saw for sale was in 257 Roberts..You might get lucky and find a well worn or crack stocked 1920,or Model54 if you want old chamberings..I was always taught that custom 98s were a non investment,but since you want a project, you could always build one in your choice of calibers.You can never get your money back from it,but you will have a nice gun to pass down..The old department store brands were usually good quality guns,and sell cheap.
 
120+ years after it was introduced, the 7x57 is still one of the most underrated cartridges ever designed. It's "intermediate" length has all but killed it off now, along with the 6.5x55 Swede. Either would be great choices.

I made my choice - a 7x57 Ruger 77 RSI.
 
Some really nice guns were sold under store brand names. Sears brand JC Higgins Mausers and Sakos come to mind, but those were only offered in popular calibers. The Mauser was only offered in 270 and 30/06.
 
+1 on the Schmidt Rubin rifles, an old unique push/pull action type rifle that shoots the 7.5x55 Swiss. Affordable and pretty accurate for an old rifle
My 96/11
image_zpsngwewxpc.jpg
 
I think one of the most underrated out there is the Italian Carcanos; i've been seeing them sell for less than beaten up Mosin Nagants lately. The cavalry carbine is about the same size as a 10/22 - very handy and light for hunting - with a bonus hinged bayonet (that is under the barrel, not on the side like an M44).
 
There are a lot of sporterized surplus rifles on the market, often for bargain prices. Any of the WW1-WW2 rifle cartridges are fine for hunting up to deer, with appropriate distance limits.

For example, a Type 38 Arisaka in 6.5X50. Or, how about the same one in 6.5-.257 Roberts? Quite a few were rechambered that way in the 50's and 60's, and it's a great cartridge. Very close to the 6.5X57 Mauser, I'm told.

Carcanos, Steyrs, early Mausers ... lots of potential good shooters out there.
 
Don't know your price point, but I have picked up a 60s Sako in 222 mag, and a ruger m77 flat bolt in 250 savage. Both ran me 450 each.
 
Some interesting suggestions here! A few of them are for rifles that appear to have really gained in value over the last decade and aren't the "bargains" they once were, but I'm still almost surprised by how the Remington 788 and the Savage 340 have still stayed relatively affordable. The Remington especially, appears to have a bit of a spotty reputation on some levels but also a certain following for having a tight lockup and being overbuilt.

I'd thought about the milsurp route, but a lot of them are for pretty powerful cartridges, like 30-06 equivalent or stronger, and a lot of them are hard to scope without doing major work. But the 6.5 Carcano is a neat option if I could find one that somebody has already scoped, or has permanently sporterized in a way that couldn't be fixed just by dropping it back into a proper stock so that I wouldn't feel bad further ruining it.
 
Stoky and I could be friends...

My first thought was the 300 Savage or the 7x57.

I like my 6.5x55 a lot!!! If you're reloading you don't see to worry if it is popular or not... And it has the benefit of being able to buy ammo...sometimes...and in some places...not CA...
Greg
 
Underrated Cartridges - Any of the .35s. Yeah I know over .30 caliber but any of the .35s will also BOOYA a Ram Silhouette even at 500 Meters :). And you can use .357/.358 pistol bullets, even cast bullets, for low cost practice. A .358 Winchester would be my first pick.

Underrated Rifles - Any Savage/Stevens Rifle that you can change the barrels yourself at home.

Just my .02,
LeonCarr
 
Last edited:
.303 Brit!
Killed everything in North America, Africa, most other continents.
Sporterized examples are CHEAP!
Not a MAGNUM, but not tossing nerf balls either.
 
Last edited:
I've never shot one so can't say if they are good but I have always wanted an M95 Steyr-Mannlicher. Seems like a neat straightpull carbine in a nice brush thumper round.
 
As I recall I purchased an Interarms Firearms rifle in the 70's and at the time it was inexpensive and was built around a Mauser action. I preferred it to my Remington 700 which was more expensive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top