44 mag mid range target loads unique vs blue dot

I have used both powders for my 44 Magnums. But I used way more Unique than Blue Dot for my handguns, but my Puma seemed to like Blue Dot better (or I did). I can't give a definite answer, BD vs U, as I worked up accurate loads for both in my 5, 44 Magnums (mostly 240-265 gr. cast bullets). Light loads of Unique seemed more consistent in accuracy than Blue Dot and I used Unique a lot for my other 4 handgun cartridges...

I much prefer Unique. For some reason, it seems to be truly excellent in the large bores like .44 and .45.

Another vote for Unique. I use it to fuel my mid-range/paper-punching .41 mag loads. I think it's just about optimal for stuff like that. With Blue Dot loaded to similar power levels, you're likely going to get slightly more recoil, more flash, and less consistent ignition/velocities.

http://www.alliantpowder.com/getting_started/safety/safety_notices.aspx
quote from Alliant

• Blue Dot® should NOT be used in the 41 Magnum cartridge (all bullet weights).

Unique gets my vote.

Both will work fine. (BTW, a .41 is not a .357 nor a .44). BlueDot will fill the case a bit better and can give slightly more velocity if needed. I usually prefer BD in my reduced loads, but I would not be afraid of using Unique if velocity is not important.


.

Very interesting answers. Unique is one of the worst metering powders I use!

Unique for target loads. Blue Dot works well for heavy loads although I don't use it much in 44.

Unique, never had a problem with metering but then I weight each load.

For midrange Loads in 44 mag 2400 Bluedot and Unique BlueDot is a good powder it was my replacement for 2400 when we had the shortage

unique for me for my 44 mag loads. then it is 2400 and/or h110.

I use 8.0 gr. of Unique with 240 or 250 gr. LSWCs for .44+P loads.
I use 10.0 gr. of Unique with 240 gr. XTPs for milder mag loads.
I use 19.6 gr. of 2400 with 240 gr. XTPs for my hottler handgun loads and rifle loads.
I have no experience with Blue Dot.

Unique for your application. When I made moose hunting loads with 300 gr. XTP's, I used Blue Dot.

I don’t load for the .44 mag, but I do for the .41 mag, ATLDave couldn’t have said it better. Unique for my target loads.

Unique has proven to give very accurate medium loads from my SBH. 9.0 grains under a 240 grain laser cast bullet gave 1.5" groups at 25 yards. I never even bothered to try a different charge or bullet as 1.5" or better with a revolver and I am happy.

I liked bluedot with 300 gr bullets

9gr unique rmr 240gr plated.

SW 629 classic with supported forearm

Not done testing but last range trip with that gun I had an issue that didn't allow me to continue testing

9.5 gr of Unique and a 240 LSWC at 15 yards. Averaged 1134 fps.

While not a real mild load this worked good for me in an old 3 screw Blackhawk, 20.5 grs. Hercules 2400 under a 240 gr. Hornady XTP. Max is 22grs. in my old Lyman manual and 22.2 grs. is max in an old Speer. I felt no need to abuse the old girl or myself...