A few possible causes.
Lubrication on the hammer hooks will cause doubling, which is the term applied to what you are experiencing. Remover the trigger group, clean well, lubricate (avoid the hammer hooks) and reinstall.
"Milking" the trigger. The Garand is unlike a bolt gun, or even an AR. Squeezing the trigger and then holding before resetting can cause doubling. It happens to me most often during cold temperatures.
Slam firing. It is possible, although not probable that the firing pin will slam forward when the bolt closes just enough to detonate a primer. Probability is increased with soft primers, but I have yet to experience this using standard CCI LR Primers. I don't pay extra for the mil spec No. 34 primers. In years past, I used Wnn LR primers without an issue. However...many times I have removed an unfired cartridge from the rifle, I have noted a small indent in the primer where the pin lightly struck it. This is true even after completely stripping, cleaning, and reassembling the bolt with all new springs. The Garand isn't the only semiauto loader of that time/design to have this issue. (The Mas 49 does it as well.) There is a member here who goes by the screen name slamfire who explained this to me in a very well written dissertation. You might try to find it.
Lastly, I I highly doubt that your reload recipe is relevant to this issue. That is a fairly common combination amongst High Power and Service Rifle competitors. (Although, I think the use of 4064 is more prevalent with the168 grn HPBT, and 4895 is used with a 200 grn projectile. Lighter projectiles at the 200 and 300 yrd lines and the 168 w/ 4064 reserved for the 600 yrd prone.