Is buffaloarms.com a reliable seller/website?

Quite. I have bought at least 40 lbs of Black Powder from them, dies, thousands of bullets, brass, and books from them. They are an excellent retailer and a great supporter of the black powder shooting community. First class.

Yes.

I have bought from them several times with no problems but check prices first as they are not always the least expensive option.

Very good experiences with them. Always a great selection.

They are local to me, I didn't even know

I like them. A great selection of goods and fair prices.

I'll check them out. I usually deal with https://www.muzzle-loaders.com/

My only problem with BACO is their shipping charges can be steep to the point of painful. I try to order enough stuff from them each time to make it worth the cost of shipping.

Dave

I bought two rifles from them: a Cimarron 1860 Henry Military Model and an 1873 Sporting Rifle. Both shipped to my transfer dealer with no issues.

I have bought odds and ends from them, they are a reputable dealer.
They list a lot of oddball ammo, it is my first stop when somebody asks about shooting his old or foreign gun.

If I were a dishonest man I would say no, just to protect my source. Sadly that business is great and the people working there. Buy with confidence.

they are an awesome company to deal with !!!!

I ordered kirst konverter set from them. Got it to me several days ahead of schedule. They even arranged with FedEx to hold onto the package so I can pick it up rather than leave it on my very exposed doorstep, so I didn't have to deal with FedEx's system. Can't say I have any complaints. They did warn me that there would be a delay due to the volume of orders, but their idea of a delay is not the same as mine, it was much faster than what they quoted.