Depends, iirc e tip I s all copper, so longer than a standard cup and core bullet. What is your rifle twist rate? How much free bore does your barrel have? What length is your magazine as that is a determining factor in col. Either bullet should work on deer but the e tip likely needs a higher velocity for expansion down range which limits its range some.
My grandaughters, savage m11 has a mag length of nearly 3 inches but free bore is shorter, found that in this rifle a col of 2.675 in this rifle produced the best accuracy with 100 gr hornandy btsp. It has a 22 inch barrel and a 1:9 in twist rate.