My SP101 fiveguns have 2.25" barrels, but they are my most-carried firearms, period. 24/7, always, everywhere, as "back-up" while in police uniform and frequently "primary" or "first among equals" while out of uniform. Heft and shootability are positive attributes in my mind. It's most important to hold the SP101 high on the backstrap while shooting magnums, as this minimizes the kick into something quite controllable, and not painful. I have never gotten around to buying a 3" SP101, though I have come close a few times. I have a 4" Ruger Speed Six that is quite packable, and makes a 3" SP101 less of a priority. I do have a J-frame Airweight, a Performance Center variant of the M642 labeled "M430," and I rarely carry it anymore, as the need for something that small and light is minimal, and I do appreciate the additional destructive power of 357 ammo.