Thanks for the input guys. I do like the looks of that Sourdough from Simply Rugged. I'm going to send them an email and ask a couple of questions about that particular holster.
This is not a CCW piece. I have a dozen other pieces that are suitable for concealment... just don't like bulk on my hip regardless. I probably won't carry this much anyway; if I have it on it means I'm in the Beartooth/Teton/Absoraka area of the state where the big fuzzy things live. Part of the reason I want a belt holster is that I can use it on my backpack that's rigged to take a holster, and take it off and put on my belt when we get to the destination.
I also want a chest or shoulder rig, but I'm not fond of the looks of the GrizzlyTuff unit. I want something smaller than that... I'm kind of a minimalist when it comes to holsters. Any other thoughts on those?