PT1911 needs a real smith for once.

Status
Not open for further replies.

DasFriek

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2009
Messages
1,498
I usually do all my own work and repair on this gun, But this time im out of my league.
First off ive found that my slide now has wiggle room after 2k rounds, It hasn't affected accuracy or anything else for that matter. But it was tight when i bought it. So i need the slide to frame refitted.

Secondly i want the billboards on the slide ground off.

Then i want a nice dark black coating that when applied doesn't add thickness like parkerizing does, But that is just as durable for a ccw weapon. Most likely in a semi gloss/matte finish.
Nothing shiny, But nothing thats parkerized flat.
This would include just 1 color and the whole gun including the small parts.
There are so many coatings out there im kinda lost

Being the gun is only a $550 gun id like to keep this reasonable as possible.

So here is what i need.
Smith who is reasonable price wise who can do all listed below.
Cost effective but durable coating that adds very little thickness when applied, Whats the best?
Able to machine the slides billboards off.
Tighten the slide and frame fit.

I dont plan on doing this for a few months until i get some bills paid off, But id like to start looking now so i know what i want and can find a good smith and reasonable prices.
 
I'm going to tell you right now, you're going to be looking at at least $500 worth of work on a $550 gun that you can better replace with a Rock Island 1911 for $450. It sounds to me like the PT1911 was made of substandard alloy. Having a gunsmith refit it isn't going to change that, and it will just continue to get worse until metal fatigue finally destroys it for good. You're better off just replacing it for something better and cheaper. The Rock Island 1911's have a very good track record.
 
That metal treatment looks awesome.
By wiggle room i mean the slide can be slightly moved left and right like its sloppy on the frame.

I think you guys may have a good point, And it may not be worth investing any more money into the gun. It was just a thought as i was replacing the firing group due to a botched trigger job. Thats only $70 and reusable high end parts if the gun dies.

The gun is an all steel gun with 2000 rounds threw it.
Is it possible a 22lb recoil spring which has worked great and makes the gun shoot so smooth and level that it battered the slide every time it closed?

The bad part was i just decided to not buy another 1911 since this one shoots so well and will be even better with the new fire group. Now i need to re-evaluate that.

If it becomes unreliable it wont be hard at all to get rid of as i do ccw the gun and thats unacceptable there.
 
I see more to the story there is...I was going to defend Taurus as a PT1911AR owner myself.

But Jeez...a 22lb recoil spring? Stock is 16lbs, even heavy duty is 18.5...

Quite possible that you did wreck the frame with that heavy spring in there.

As I've said Taurus problems usually originate with owner inducement, IMVHO. I'm not knocking you, but...
 
Well Vinnay if you weren't knocking me im sure you could have worded that not so condescending.

Now I may be an idiot, but there is one thing I am not, sir, and that, sir, is an idiot.
I may call myself one, But you sir cannot.

Now that im done joking around ill be asking around for other peoples opinions. And most likley be replacing the spring if it is in fact creating more of an issue than saving the frame from a battering.
 
Yes, 16# is considered standard today and, in reality, a 14# will work just fine for standard velocity loads if the gun is right. 22# is too much spring and will cause accelerated wear to the gun over time. Regarding the other thread, if it takes a spring heavier than 16# to make your 5" gun run, something is wrong with your gun. That's from 46 years of owning and shooting many many thousands of rounds through 30+ personally owned 1911s and quite a few more owned by the US Army.
 
Last edited:
Id prefer to discuss the recoil spring in the other thread as this one is about other concerns. My gun will run fine on 16lb springs too 22lbs springs, Its just what i happened to put in it.

We can move this discussion to the other thread if you would like to discuss it further.
 
Dude, listen to reason...

You bought a cookie cutter "semi-custom" (that's nonsense) Taurus.

The money you put into it cannot even be remotely recouped should you want to sell and the pistol isn't worth the work you are going to put in it.

Why would you double the price of a low-end 1911 with custom work?

If you really want a custom 1911, build one. If you want a functional and yet nice 1911, look into other factory pistols that fit your wants/needs.

I'll tell you what, I've got a semi-custom Smith 1911SC and its the best little 1911 I've ever owned. I even sold my Springfield TRP because this one is all I need. Smith totally backs it too.

I found it barely used for 800. It's got all the fixin's and a great trigger. PLUS its light.

Don't put money into that pistol. Get it back to stock. Sell it for 400 and buy the pistol you want for 900-1200.

There are plenty of beautiful "safe queens" out there you can pick up.

The Smith line aren't "true" to the 1911 design but they function. Better yet, if you can find someone dumping their "customized" 1911, like I did, you get the work you want, for a quarter of the price.

I got a performance center Smith for cookie cutter price.

I recommend you look at 4.25" 1911's for CC.

Good luck!
 
Unless you are really attached to that Taurus you might consider using it as a trade for something else.

Around here for what you plan on spending for upgrades and repairs, throwing in the Taurus as part trade you could step up to a Springfield or Colt for the same money. My Rock Island is a great gun also for less than the cost of you planned expense.

I understand customizing a gun to your specs, done it plenty of times myself. You could do some extra work on some of those other models and have a better weapon (IMHO) and it would have more value to it at the end of the day.

I would vote to move on to another model.
 
First off ive found that my slide now has wiggle room after 2k rounds, It hasn't affected accuracy or anything else for that matter. But it was tight when i bought it. So i need the slide to frame refitted.

why bother? if there are no reliability and or accuracy issues then why get it refitted?

and agree with the above posters the work you want is not worth it considering the base gun being a taurus IMHO.
 
From post #6
I think you guys may have a good point, And it may not be worth investing any more money into the gun. It was just a thought as i was replacing the firing group due to a botched trigger job. Thats only $70 and reusable high end parts if the gun dies.

Im just gonna replace the fire control group i botched and thats it, No more money will be invested in it. I do agree with everyone this isnt the gun to put money into even if i really like the gun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top