Today, 04:10 PM #65
TimboKhan
Moderator
Join Date: April 14, 2005
Location: Greeley, CO
Posts: 6,282
Here is a summary of this thread:
1. .45 ACP is probably not a suitable bear round.
2. Barring purchasing a new and more suitable firearm, bear spray is an acceptable-to-good alternative.
Thats pretty much that. Timothy Treadwell being compared to a vet offends me personally, but being personally offended isn't why this thread is being closed. It is being closed because at this point there just isn't much else to say.
__________________
First Battalion, Seventh Marines, 1990-1994
Dear TimboKhan, just making an analogy that Treadwell did in fact survive 13 years among the bears which is a statement of fact whether folks like that or not. The surprising fact is that he lasted 13 years which is way beyond any predictions of what his actions should have resulted. We all know of his eccentricities and delusional thinking, but heck, he did understand body language among bears and in that one aspect, he did what is recommended standing his ground.
If he had added an electric fence and pepper spray, I suspect he would still be out there telling his little bears, "I love you." In that aspect, I respect him for having the courage to stand his ground against these huge bears. I have watched his films over several years and it is clear that Treadwill did understand the dangers including the risk of death.
I have admiration for any person that faces his fears and confronts them. Whatever his psychological motivations, Treadwell did in fact live in close proximity to these bears for 13 years. Did his lack of concern for his own safety and his girl friend's safety ultimately lead to his death, absolutely!!
Sadly, his outcome was completely predictable in the end but I do respect people that as crazy as they may be who confront their internal demons. How many of us have ever confronted them in such a direct manner? Yes, plenty to criticize and condemn in his actions, but sorry, I admire his courage as well.
I believe our fascination with Treadwell as a nation must stem from an underlying admiration of what he did even though his actions are and should be condemned in their totality but in the end, I cannot condemn him in total personally. Just my own opinion and others of course are free to disagree.
BTW, I am a veteran of the Armed forces and I served honorably for 9 years and was promoted to the rank of Major before I left for civilian life. I likewise have the utmost respect for the sacrifices that all veterans gave in service to this nation.