1911 Sig Scorpion Carry Traditional Review

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 24, 2007
Messages
1,882
By Mark Singer
Pistol Instructor at Safe Direction Firearms
Website Address: safedirection.org

Some firearms are iconic in the American Culture. One would have to be the Thompson SMG as it conjures up memories of the gangsters of the Prohibition era. Another would be the M1 Garand, Called “the greatest battle implement ever devised” by General George S. Patton.1 And arguably the most iconic semi-automatic pistol in the American culture is the Colt M1911 pistol conceived of by a brilliant firearms designer John Moses Browning. The M1911 served as the standard issue handgun for the U.S. Armed Forces from 1911 to 1985 and is still in select use today.2

With the popularity of the 1911 pistol within the Armed Forces, it is no surprise that the civilian population took a liking to the design as well; with numerous manufacturers making their own versions of the Colt original. SIG Arms famous for their traditional double action line of pistols, most notably the P226, joined the 1911 market in 2004 with their own take on the 1911. They took some poetic license and created a 1911 with what has been described by gun owners as a “SIG profile” slide. The SIG profile slide adds a bit of mass and squares off the rounded traditional lines of the venerable 1911 pistol. SIG entered the 1911 market with their new SIG GSR 1911, with GSR meaning Granite Series Rail3. It was released in a Commander length barrel of 4.25” which SIG calls the “Carry” frame size and a Government length barrel of 5” which SIG simply refers to as the “Full” size frame. While the pistol was well received, it received criticism from fans of the 1911. Not only was the criticism aimed at the slide’s shape and appearance but due to the unique profile of the slide finding a holster became that much harder. Well, SIG was listening.
Sig.jpg

http://www.dayattherange.com is a self funded (no advertisements ) website dedicated to provide unbiased reviews. It is the owner and the author's way of giving back and sharing a great sport and part of America's tradition. Stop by and let us know what you think about this article, by leaving comments.
 
Last edited:
While the pistol was well received, it received criticism from fans of the 1911. Not only was the criticism aimed at the slide’s shape and appearance but due to the unique profile of the slide finding a holster became that much harder.

Many (not me) who prioritize "traditionalism" when it comes to the appearance of a Model 1911 would object to the looks of an external extractor as used by SIG, Smith & Wesson and other manufacturers.
 
Many (not me) who prioritize "traditionalism" when it comes to the appearance of a Model 1911 would object to the looks of an external extractor as used by SIG, Smith & Wesson and other manufacturers.
I agree that the traditionalists have always opposed the external extractor and I used to be one of them. I wrote the article above and I was a purist. I never wanted an external extractor and finally decided to just try one out.

In my opinion, they work just as well as the internal ones. I have also found that they don't seem to mar the rim of the brass as much as the internal extractors often seem to do without some tuning.
 
Nice review, Mr. Revolverguy. I've also have enjoyed very good success shooting my Model TTT. One of the biggest reasons I opted for this model over most other SIG 1911 variants was due to the compact, yet adjustable rear sight. To my eyes, it's also a very nice looking and distinctive appearing pistol. But more than anything that persuaded me to invest in this SIG is the fine finish and workmanship exhibited. A great pistol that looks, shoots and handles as good or better than many much higher priced equivalents.
 
Got to the range today to start breaking in the new SIG 1911 Carry Scorpion. I had some of the same issues I've read others were having: only one of the factory mags continued to feed good. I had picked up a Chip McCormick that worked pretty good, but occasionally both of the good mags would give a misfeed. As a quick fix on the range I put a drop of Ultra Lube gun oil on the ramp and around the rim of the chamber, and that solved the problem for today.
Anybody got a permanent solution?
Other than that I LOVE this gun. Powerful and accurate! I fired about 200 rounds through it.
 
Weird, mine did not have this issue. I would kept it well lubed and shoot the snot out of it until it polished itself out. Beware the dremel, it has destroyed many a gun. I would also recommend some Wilson ETM mags; I have never had a problem with their functioning.

If the problem persists, contact SIG. They have amazing CS, I sent in a 229 before. With the repair and shipping both ways it was a two week turn around.
 
Got to the range today to start breaking in the new SIG 1911 Carry Scorpion. I had some of the same issues I've read others were having: only one of the factory mags continued to feed good. I had picked up a Chip McCormick that worked pretty good, but occasionally both of the good mags would give a misfeed. As a quick fix on the range I put a drop of Ultra Lube gun oil on the ramp and around the rim of the chamber, and that solved the problem for today.

Anybody got a permanent solution?

Other than that I LOVE this gun. Powerful and accurate! I fired about 200 rounds through it.


What ammo were you shooting?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top