TrapperReady
Member
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2003
- Messages
- 2,732
I should probably just PM Steve about this , but I thought I'd throw it out there for discussion.
My wife has started seriously considering switching to an O/U. She currently shoots a Benelli 12ga and hits pretty well with it most of the time. However, for a number of reasons, she's been eyeing O/Us recently.
There are really three games she plays with any regularity: 16 yard trap, sporting clays and 5-stand. Although she shoots league rounds for winter trap and sporting clays, she doesn't really care if she's competetive. She just wants to have fun and break targets more often than not. At trap, her average is in the upper teens and she shoots around 50% on most clays courses.
A couple other pieces of background. First of all, she does not seem to be particularly recoil sensitive. Secondly, she's tiny and the overall weight of the gun is an important factor. Lastly, she prefers an action which is not bank-vault tight, as that can require too much arm and hand strength to open.
As we've looked around, she found a 12ga. Browning Feather XS that she liked. It seemed to fit her well, and even with 30" barrels, it was of a reasonable weight for her.
Here's where I'm looking for input. All else being equal, I'm thinking that a 28ga O/U would be perfect for her. It would be more scaled to her physical dimensions, without offering up the punishing recoil of a lightweight 12ga. A 20ga would also be lighter, but the lightweight 20ga shotguns I've used seem to generate nearly as much recoil as their bigger brothers.
Now, if I convince her to go with a 28ga, how much is she likely to be giving up to the 12ga in terms of absolute clay-breaking performance? Remember that we're talking 16 yard trap and sporting clays. What I want to try to avoid is her getting a new gun and then becoming discouraged by her shooting.
I guess I'd like to open a discussion on 28ga vs. 12ga, also desiring comments on the viability of 20ga as middle-ground alternative. If you have specific brands or models in mind, please feel free to mention them.
FWIW, I'm NOT (no, really, I mean it) trying to do this as a way for me to end up with a 28ga. I've got that Model 42 to play with now.
My wife has started seriously considering switching to an O/U. She currently shoots a Benelli 12ga and hits pretty well with it most of the time. However, for a number of reasons, she's been eyeing O/Us recently.
There are really three games she plays with any regularity: 16 yard trap, sporting clays and 5-stand. Although she shoots league rounds for winter trap and sporting clays, she doesn't really care if she's competetive. She just wants to have fun and break targets more often than not. At trap, her average is in the upper teens and she shoots around 50% on most clays courses.
A couple other pieces of background. First of all, she does not seem to be particularly recoil sensitive. Secondly, she's tiny and the overall weight of the gun is an important factor. Lastly, she prefers an action which is not bank-vault tight, as that can require too much arm and hand strength to open.
As we've looked around, she found a 12ga. Browning Feather XS that she liked. It seemed to fit her well, and even with 30" barrels, it was of a reasonable weight for her.
Here's where I'm looking for input. All else being equal, I'm thinking that a 28ga O/U would be perfect for her. It would be more scaled to her physical dimensions, without offering up the punishing recoil of a lightweight 12ga. A 20ga would also be lighter, but the lightweight 20ga shotguns I've used seem to generate nearly as much recoil as their bigger brothers.
Now, if I convince her to go with a 28ga, how much is she likely to be giving up to the 12ga in terms of absolute clay-breaking performance? Remember that we're talking 16 yard trap and sporting clays. What I want to try to avoid is her getting a new gun and then becoming discouraged by her shooting.
I guess I'd like to open a discussion on 28ga vs. 12ga, also desiring comments on the viability of 20ga as middle-ground alternative. If you have specific brands or models in mind, please feel free to mention them.
FWIW, I'm NOT (no, really, I mean it) trying to do this as a way for me to end up with a 28ga. I've got that Model 42 to play with now.