I didn't have much chance to write yesterday so I only gave a very quick reply.
I'll explain here.
I'd go with the Ruger Redhawk and some customization.
The redhawk is an awesome platform. Super robust, points well, heavy enough to soak up recoil, basically everything a .44mag should be.
So you get the Redhawk (let's say $650-700?). Then, get a trigger job, refinish, new sights, dehorn, chamfer chambers, recrown, nice grips, basically everything you could want for another $500-700. So far you are still only $1150-1400 in the hole depending on which work you want done and at what price.
You end up with an outstanding firearm, that is customized to be exactly what you want. And you still have enough money left over for a reloading set-up, scope+ammo, or just a bunch of ammo.
It's really an epic win all the way around.