IIRC, once the dimples are filed down, the old mag cap will no longer stay seated, as it is designed to be depressed past the dimples into the mag tube then twisted 90 degrees to lock it in there.
If you already have an 870 that you want to file dimples off of, that's something to consider...you will be committing to that mag extension. If you are planning to purchase one and just want an extended mag, I'd suggest the 870 Express HD, as there are no dimples in that mag tube (at least not in mine).
Finally, if the mag extension is any more than +1, I'd say you need a barrel clamp. They're actually open on top so should accomodate a vent rib bbl.
Hope this helps.