A History Lesson: The Onion Field

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fred Fuller

Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 26, 2004
Messages
21,215
Location
AL, NC
While ST&T is here primarily for the edification of armed citizens, the entire community of those who go about armed has learned important lessons from pivotal events that loom large in our collective past. One of those influential events happened at a place known as The Onion Field, and the events which transpired there in 1963 continue to touch the lives of trainers and students today.

From trainer John Farnam:

http://www.defense-training.com/quips/29Aug12.html
The Onion Field
29 Aug 12

The last "Onion Field" perpetrator now dead!

In 1963, I was a high-school senior living in the Chicago suburb of Wheaton, and I well remember the dreadful event that would later be canonized in Joseph Wambaugh's classic 1973 record, "The Onion Field." Waumbaugh was uniquely qualified to comment, as he himself had once been an officer with the LAPD. Today, he is seventy-five.

Late on 9 March 63 (Saturday), two LAPD officers, Ian Campbell and Karl Hettinger, were outflanked during a traffic-stop and ultimately disarmed and kidnaped by two desperate armed robbers, Gregory Powell and Jimmy Lee Smith. Both Powell and Smith were both in their early thirties at the time, but Powell, a career violent criminal even then, was the more dangerous of the two. Smith was just a six-time loser, tagging along.

The two officers were taken at gunpoint to a (then) isolated farm field near Bakersfield (onion field). There is little doubt Powell at least intended to murder both officers. He succeeded in Campbell's case. Campbell was precipitously shot in the face by Powell and died more or less instantly. Hettinger then broke loose and ran, dodging Powell's bullets, and successfully eluded his captors, ultimately reaching a farmhouse and safety.

The two suspects were located and arrested within a day. Both were tried, convicted, and sentenced to death. Both death sentences were later reduced to life imprisonment after lengthy re-trials. Lead investigator was Pierce R Brooks, whom I met years later, after he authored the first widely-circulated book on individual police tactics, "Officer Down, Code Three," a classic, even today, and I still quote from it often! Pierce and I lectured, side by side, at The Traffic Institute at Northwestern University in Evanston, IL in the early 1980s. He was a wonderful mentor and friend and greatly influenced me and the way I teach . He died in 1998 at the age of seventy-five.

Karl Hettinger, though he lived through the incident, was thereafter a tortured soul until his untimely death at age fifty-nine in 1994. Forced to testify multiple times, he painfully recounted details of that fateful night, over and over again. As a result, his mental health suffered severely. Like Mark Reno at the Little Big Horn when he became the scape-goat for Custer's debacle, Hettinger was unfairly blamed by many for Campbell's death. No LAPD officer in 1963 had ever received any training in kidnap procedure, and, when Hettinger precipitously ran away after his partner was shot, he only did what I'm sure I would have done! In 1963, LAPD officers, including Campbell and Hettinger, did not carry back-up guns. Today, the wise among us do!

Jimmy Lee Smith was paroled in 1986, but repeatedly violated and was re-arrested on unrelated charges, mostly drugs, multiple times. Back in prison, he died of natural causes (heart attack) in 2007, at the age of seventy-six.

Powell became eligible for parol in 2010, but was repeatedly denied, partially because of passionate testimony on the part of Ian Campbell's daughter. Late on 12 Aug 12 (Sunday), Powell succumbed to prostate cancer in a prison hospice, having spent the last fifty years of his life continuously incarcerated. He was seventy-nine. When he murdered Campbell, he was just thirty.

Powell and Smith had no contact with each other while in the CA Prison System.

All four main Onion Field characters, so meticulously and painstakingly described by Wambaugh in his book, are now dead. That chapter in police/criminal history has finally come to a close!

At Campbell's funeral, his family arranged for bagpipes to play, as Campbell was himself a bagpipe enthusiast. Bagpipe funerals, in honor of |Campbell, have since become a tradition with LAPD, and many other departments.

The 1979 film version of Wambaugh's book starred a young Ted Danson, playing the role of Ian Campbell. It was Danson's first major role and launched his acting career.

When I became a police officer in WI in 1971, fresh out of the Marine Corps and back from Vietnam, the Onion Field was a hot topic of discussion, even two years before Wambaugh's book was published. I surely remember thoughts of the incident haunting me many times as I was out on patrol.

Whether in the police business or not, you have to be alert, prepared, and always have a plan. The world has not improved since 1963! The Onion Field Incident is now just a milestone, among so many others. We forget important lessons, learned at such great cost, at our peril!

"Opportunity knocks, but seldom nags!"

/John
 
attaboy @ John Farnam

I follow his D'Quips and he sent that article to me and it brought back lots of memories as to that incident.

I was not allowed to carry a BUG when I started as LEO.

But after being well read as to this incident,the least I did was carry "Onion Field Insurance" and that consisted of a North American .22 LR in my pocket/holster at all times.

Lesson to learn in my not so humble opinion is that you have NO idea when a SHTF moment will happen.

Be prepared,please !.
 
I was just starting in police work when the Onion Field was published... it made a very serious impression on me. Wambaugh's earlier works, particularly the New Centurions, were the push that got me thinking about a career in law enforcement all those years ago. I never regretted it and went on to read everything (well almost everything he's ever written....). Looking back, sixteen years after a 22 year career I still marvel at how well he portrays that entire world (even if most of his works are set in California....).
 
The "money quote' in Farnam's retrospective (as was pointed out already) is this - Whether in the police business or not, you have to be alert, prepared, and always have a plan.

Notice there's nothing there about what caliber you need, or how many rounds, or anything else about hardware specifically. "Be alert, be prepared and always have a plan" is something every one of us can do at basically no cost, with only some elementary effort at keeping our eyes open and our heads on a swivel. That's about as basic as it gets. But it is a critical lesson, and one not to be taken for granted.

Another favorite Farnam quote: "When it's least expected, you're elected."
 
"Opportunity knocks, but seldom nags!"

That is an insightful comment wasted on most people.
Like John, Scaty, and Lemay I was a young officer when the book came out. Our academy had a four hour block of instruction on gun retention that referenced the incident. The take away was "never give up you weapon." Looking back it was simplistic, but a start.
Against dept. policy I did carry a bug, a 38 snub. It became permissable in 79.

The quote,
"Be alert, be prepared and always have a plan"
is ussualy glossed over by most. They might have 1 or two scenarios and a couple default plans, but the fail is in the ability to grow and expand thier situational awareness and mindset.
There are lessons to learn every day, all around us.
 
Have a plan, yes.

I went to the Dr. with my daughter yesterday, she has some hip problems and the doc was going over the MRI results with us. It was an hour+ drive to this specialist. We park, go inside, and I'm practically dancing in my shoes because I have to pee so bad.

Before even looking for the restroom I'd spotted 3 other exits and decided where we were going to sit in the waiting room so I could see all of them, with my back to a wall. I'd decided everyone else in the (very) large waiting room was a non-threat except for one guy off alone, covered in tattoos, who was jittery and nervous. I made sure I'd sit facing him too.

THEN we got checked in and I found a bathroom.
 
The first agency for which I worked "permitted" BUG-carry only by the lack of any policy prohibiting it. I bought mine, a Charter Arms Undercover 38, the day I was sworn in, at the uniform/equipment store I had been taken to for fitting. That gun rode BUG (ankle) duty and as an off-duty gun for a few years after that. The second agency had a written policy permitting BUG-carry, but had a list of approved weapons, and my Undercover didn't make the cut (by that time, CA didn't have the best reputation, I guess, though I don't think they really suffered until around 2000.) So, I picked up a Walther PPK/S in .380. This agency also required off-duty carry while within its jurisdiction.
I've read of many cases in which a BUG made the difference. I used one once to arm a brother officer who had inadvertently arrived on a call without his sidearm (he had been handling a prisoner, and left the booking area hastily to assist me on the call.) I gave him my sidearm, which was the same issued model as his, and carried my snub while we confronted a suspicious individual. I knew I was proficient with the little .38, but knew he would likely not be.
 
Frankly I am a bit surprised a police agency would have a policy against an officer carrying a BUG.
Can any of you LEO's shed some light on that reasoning or lack there of??

Fwiw I recently bought a another new LCP and the ffl is a young police officer that works for a small suburban police force near Houston and in our talks he mentioned he always carrys an LCP loaded with Hornady CD's in his vest.
I did not even think to ask what his departments rules were on the subject.
 
that incident changed non cops thinking too. i think prior to that there was a cooperate and maybe no one gets hurt attitude. heck even richard pryor worked the change in mindset into his act. the change being "not going anywhere and getting down on my knees ! they can shoot me right here!"... nothing good can come of letting yourself be moved to secluded place. and it seems that that type of "mad dog" killing gets more and more frequent.
 
I think this thinking of a BUG should be reviewed by the military and diplomatic services as well. A 380 with a couple mags and a few days training might go a long way in saving lives or at least elevating the cost to those who would want to do them harm both at home and abroad.
This thinking would turn things on its head for sure but the exposure that some are now under without a last ditch way to defend themselves is troubling given the savagery that is committed if captured.
 
The take away was "never give up you weapon." Looking back it was simplistic, but a start.
Note that in The Onion Field, Wambaugh defends an officer giving up his weapon, and by implication at least, blames those officers who condemned giving up weapons as the cause of Hettenger's later problems.
 
I lived next door to Karl Hettinger during my high school and college years. My step-sister was best friends with Karl's oldest daughter, and Karl and I shared interests in motorcycles. He was a good man, always willing to help, and had a terrific sense of humor. He became the right-hand man to one of our county Supervisiors, and succeeded him on the Board.

When I attended college in Sacramento, there was a floor in one of the dorm buildings designated for Criminal Justice majors. I lived there, even though I was a Business major - I intended to pursue a career in law enforcement. Also living on that floor was a tall, dark-haired beauty named Laurie Campbell - Ian Campbell's daughter.

My grandfather was a County Patrolman, killed on duty a couple years before that agency became the California Highway Patrol. My mother was one of the first female Deputy Sheriffs in our county, Dad was a probation/parole officer, and my uncle was a CHP sergeant. I guess the genes are pretty strong. I grew up around cops, respected them, and knew many that were trapped in the job long after it lost it's appeal to them. Their education and experience was all geared to law enforcement - some went on to become lawyers, some quit, many battled alcoholism, some became disabled, and a few had "gun cleaning accidents".

One summer evening, while I was home from college, Karl asked me over to "help him with" his dirtbike - really, he wanted to make sure I understood what I intended to get into. He wasn't trying to talk me into or out of the career, nor did he try to represent his situation as common - he just wanted me to know, firsthand, his experience. From what I know of Karl, it was extremely rare for him to discuss the matter, and I felt honored that he considered my future important enough to share that part of his life with me.
 
Law enforcement agencies, government agencies, human nature - we all tend to continue doing what has always worked until it fails. Sometimes those failures are spectacular and catastrophic.
 
It's interesting that you knew him Teachu2.
There was another Onion Field thread here recently that I commented in that I always felt Hettenger was wrongly villified by others in law enforcement.

RIP Mr. Hettenger.
 
One thing. The death penalties weren't overturned on appeal. It was a supreme court finding that the California death penalty, as then written was unconstitutional. It converted to life in prisonment for all those on death row, including likely the most infamous Charles Manson.

When the death penalty was reinstated, and this time passed any constitutional challanges (though no one has yet been executed) those who had been previously sentenced to death and reprieved were exempt unless they were retryed on other charges.

Interestingly, California also has the option of life without possibility of parole. But again, those previously sentenced were exempt. This is why inmates like Manson now have parole hearings on a regular basis.
 
Although I have never heard it stated I believe a lot of LEO administrators forbid the use of a BUG for fear that it would be used as a throwdown. My department did not allow BUG's until 2004. Many of us carried them anyway. I carried a NAA .22 mag in my hip pocket for so long that I wore the right side wooden grip down to the point that it had to be replaced twice. I still carry it as a BUG but it now has the oversized rubber grips.
 
My Department allowed BUGs, but you were required to qualify with it and it had to be of the same caliber as your duty gun. At the time we were required to carry a 4” revolver that had to be either a S&W, Colt or Ruger that could chamber a .38Spl. My duty gun was a S&W 66 and the BUG was a S&W 60 carried in a wallet holster in my back pocket.

I never fired the BUG on duty, but on one occasion it came out being the fastest reload that I could make. The perp went down from the 6th shot to his head from my duty gun, but at the time I didn’t know if he was not just getting behind cover.
 
@ Teachu2

WOW, that is a very interesting and touching story.

I dont 'blame' anyone for doing or not doing what I have done or believe.

I was taught that YOU know your gun is functional and loaded,that is reason enough to never surrender it.

I expect that I would watch a fellow LEO or family member die ,rather than surrender my gun .

I do know EXACTLY what will happen when I am disarmed.

Sad that what we fought for has been taken .

My "onion field insurance" paid off in the attitude that I was never to drop my guard.We were allowed to carry BUG's after a while.Then it was taken away just recently by the D.A.'s office.



After 26 years [ retired LOD stuff ] I am happy to say = I NEVER DID.
 
These milestone events are significant in part because they serve to make the rest of us THINK about things we might not have ever considered before, and plan to do things a different way if we ever face a similar situation ourselves. Oh, the same event may provoke changes in 'departmental policy' or 'training' or whatever, but the mindset changes these significant occasions prompt in the minds of individuals who go about armed, no matter what their roles, is what is truly meaningful as far as I am concerned.

The Army has referred to such things (on an Army scale) as "lessons learned" for years, and even established a center to spread the message (http://usacac.army.mil/cac2/call/index.asp). These "lessons" are important and costly, and that is why, on a smaller scale, we in the community of armed citizens should examine various "lessons learned" of potential importance to us individually as well.
 
I was deeply touched by the book.
Ian Cambell was someone who I would have loved to have called a friend--according to the book he had the soul of a poet and was very intelligent and well read.
When I became a court officer this incident was discussed in great detail.
Years later one of our officers was off duty and was in a drugstore that was being robbed.
Due to fear of endangering the customers he did not pull his gun--until the bad guy started herding the victims to a back room.
A quick draw and two shots from his .38 ended the encounter a happy ending.
He credited the recounting of the onion field incident as saving his life.
May both these fine officers R.I. P. while the perps can rot in hell.
 
I read the book a few years ago, there was a LONG backstory that I had a tough time getting through but the details of the actual incident were very well written.
 
Thanks for sharing, Teachu2. May the officers rest in peace.

I am fortunate that I have worked since 1983 for a large PD that has seemingly always allowed multiple handguns. (My actual sworn date was in early 1984.) The Onion Field incident was part of our academy curriculum, if I recall correctly.
Some lessons are written in blood.

We must qual with all weapons we plan to use for police and defensive purposes, on or off the clock; the computer program has "room" for eight weapons. My first secondary handgun was a Model 60, with primary being a Model 686. Today, it usually an SP101 on the smaller side, and a strategically placed 4" S&W Model 19, acting as "back-up" to the primary duty SIG P229R. (.40 is now the mandated duty cartridge.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top