it is supposed to actually be faster,
Again, not possible. You're starting out by throwing your force hard into pushing the gun in the wrong direction. Then you have to recover from that thrust, change directions and present the gun. A trainer or experienced competitor could show you this very clearly in about 5 seconds.
and it requires only gross motor skill
Lots of striker-fired, double-action only, and DA/SA guns in the world. None of them require anything more than draw and press the trigger.
I wont carry cocked and locked cocked and decocked or any way with a round in the chamber.
But you realize your feelings on this place you in an extreme minority of shooters, and folks who carry a gun for any reason.
Any negligent discharge is scary and carries risks of tragedy. But there is no pandemic of rampant negligent discharges taking place. They are pretty darned rare, considering how many guns there are in the world. This isn't a pressing problem in need of a solution.
the only valid point I have seen is reholstering
Really? Well, we tried.
but, its the draw that much be quick
Quick, yes, but also it must bring the gun into action ready to go, instantly. Any step that starts with chambering a round introduces a failure point. If folks can short-stroke a pump shotgun under stress, I guarantee you they'll be able to short-stroke this holster mechanism and come up with either an empty chamber or a jammed gun. GUARANTEED.
Sometimes, when we draw, it is really darned important that the gun work RIGHT NOW.
chances are your not reholstering if you had to use it, you are just dropping it.
Noooo, no that's not true at all. Your holster needs to stand ready to accept your gun, without looking and without fumbling, and one-handed because there are LOTS of things you might need your hands free for, and then need to have the gun at the ready again quickly.
And I thought you said this was better as a duty holster? How does a cop cuff and secure a suspect? Throw his gun down? Stop and unload it and re-holster? Not even really a feasible workaround for that problem.
But if this was used by someone for a self-defense gun, you do not throw down your gun when the trouble appears to cease. That's A possibility, if the police arrive on scene while you still have your gun out. (Well, maybe place it carefully on the ground.) But that's not, by far, the most likely result of a self-defense situation, whether or not shots are fired.
Need a holster that works as a holster should work. This design just doesn't.