A Poll for a CC Gun...
- Thread starter RonGoode
- Start date
- Status
I would deff go with the Kimber. I am an avid glock fan as i won two of them but i'm not a big fan of their compacs cause my hands dont fit right on them. And the last time i held a kimber compac it just felt like it belonged there.
I really would go for the Glock 30 over the G36 or Kimber compact. I like 1911s, but when you start chopping that barrel down, you eventually affect reliability. You might get a good one. You might get one that chokes every other mag and needs a little tuning to put right.
I voted G36 but would prefer the G30. As to the Kimber, I'd pass on their chopped 1911s in favor of an LDA-triggered Para made for the task. Yep, they work and are super smooth.
As a huge 1911 and Glock fan, I'm going to have to vote the G36 out of a compact 1911 vs. the G36. I like the full size 1911 or bust. It is so easy for me to conceal that I can't imagine wanting to get something that is different than it was originally designed. I'll stick with the full size ideally, but I'm going to have to rate the G36 higher in this battle.
Well, between a sub 4" 1911 and a G36, I'd probably go for the Glock... I know opinions and experiences are varied, but I've seen too many 3" to 3.5" 1911s not work consistantly while G36s pretty much go bang every time.
Now, if we include 4" and 4.25" 1911s, I'd lean towards one of them over the Glock.
Now, if we include 4" and 4.25" 1911s, I'd lean towards one of them over the Glock.
I'd say go with the Glock 36.
I've also seen lots of reliability problems with the small 1911's. I bought a V10 that'd FTF, FTE alot. Also search about low velocitiy and keyholing issues with the higher grain loads.
The Glock .45's have an octagonal cut barrel, which means no lead.
Click Me
The best part about Glocks is the HUGE aftermarket. If the 36 isn't perfect for you out of the box there is an ocean of connectors, springs, trigger bars, sights, mag floor plates, ext slide stop levers, etc.
I'd also suggest holding the 1911 and the Glock at the same time. Now, which one would you want to carry all day?
I've also seen lots of reliability problems with the small 1911's. I bought a V10 that'd FTF, FTE alot. Also search about low velocitiy and keyholing issues with the higher grain loads.
The Glock .45's have an octagonal cut barrel, which means no lead.
Click Me
The best part about Glocks is the HUGE aftermarket. If the 36 isn't perfect for you out of the box there is an ocean of connectors, springs, trigger bars, sights, mag floor plates, ext slide stop levers, etc.
I'd also suggest holding the 1911 and the Glock at the same time. Now, which one would you want to carry all day?
chevrofreak
Member
My favorite style of pistol is the 1911, but I would not bet my life on a 3" bbl version. I know many people have good results, but my personal experience is that they are not nearly reliable enough. I have them, but will not carry them.
If it has to be limited to these two choices, go with the Glock (gad, I can't believe I wrote that!!!!!)
If it has to be limited to these two choices, go with the Glock (gad, I can't believe I wrote that!!!!!)
If it works for you I would go with the Glock. It would be thinner and ligher making an easier carry package. Like any carry gun you'll want to test it for functionality with your loads.
Neither
LW Commander or Commander slide and Officers frame. 1911's that have a barrel length under 4" can be fussy.
ZM
LW Commander or Commander slide and Officers frame. 1911's that have a barrel length under 4" can be fussy.
ZM
GunNut
Member
Glock.
Yeah, they ain't pretty, but they will go bang everytime you pull the trigger.
I've got a Glock 30, and actually really like it.
I'm thinking about trying to trade a Colt Combat Elite for a Glock 36 or maybe a 19.
Biggest thing you need to decide is if you are a 1911 guy or not.
Steve
Yeah, they ain't pretty, but they will go bang everytime you pull the trigger.
I've got a Glock 30, and actually really like it.
I'm thinking about trying to trade a Colt Combat Elite for a Glock 36 or maybe a 19.
Biggest thing you need to decide is if you are a 1911 guy or not.
Steve
Glock. 
It's lightweight and simple. 1911's are great, but I don't think they make good choice for CCW. They are heavy, and the rear sight, grip or magazine plate may wear holes in any shirt or jacket you wear over it. I knew a feller who had a Colt Defender, and it did that. The Glock's rear right, grip and magazine is friendly to clothing.
It's lightweight and simple. 1911's are great, but I don't think they make good choice for CCW. They are heavy, and the rear sight, grip or magazine plate may wear holes in any shirt or jacket you wear over it. I knew a feller who had a Colt Defender, and it did that. The Glock's rear right, grip and magazine is friendly to clothing.
I'd go with a compact size Kimber (4"bbl, Occifer's frame). Owned Glocks and 1911's and the 1911's just work better for me.
CCW
Para Ordnance LTC 4.25 inch barrel, alloy frame, 45ACP in a FIST #42 Driving to Crossdraw holster.
Para Ordnance LTC 4.25 inch barrel, alloy frame, 45ACP in a FIST #42 Driving to Crossdraw holster.
The 36 is one of the compacts. It is a lower capacity version of the 30. Frankly I can't think of a reason for it other than, possibly, some people not being able to grip the Glock 30. It does have a slimmer grip, but as far as I can tell, it's got the same fat slide as the 30, so it really doesn't have a concealability avantage over the 30.
36 or 30, depending on your hands. Both will serve you well. I have both and like both. If you are comfortable carrying the heavier, fatter 30, go for that.
- Status
Similar threads
