AG Russel Folding Sting/Frame-Lock Spear Point and Spyderco Paramilitary

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jimmie

Member.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
619
I'm looking for a new EDC for home and overseas. Corrosion resistance and edge retention are my two biggest requirements. One made in the US would be nice. I've been carrying a CRKT M16-13T. I was a little turned off by it this summer when some rust spots formed on the blade. They polished out, but I wasn't expecting it.

I've found 3 that I think would fit the bill. I'd like any feedback or experiences with any of them.
Any advantages/disadvantages to any of these? Steel differences? Ergonomics? Thanks!
 
No direct experience with the folding Sting, but I have several fixed blades of that model. AG designed the original Sting to be a double-edged knife that had some utility outside of stabbing. In that, he was successful. For a dagger, the Sting is actually pretty useful. In the folding model, as it comes from AG, the upper edge isn't sharpened, but you still have the same basic dagger blade shape with its issues of wedginess. If you go with one of the two Russells, the grind of the spearpoint will give you greater utility for things like slicing, IMO. That blade looks very similar, in fact, to the old Benchmark Ninja which was designed by Blackie Collins. Despite the goofy name, it was actually a damned good little fixed blade utility knife. Since AG Russell distributed the last of them a couple years ago, it wouldn't surprise me if that is where the inspiration for the spearpoint blade lies.
I own a bunch of AG Russell's knives, and none of them are junk.

OTOH, I also own a bunch of Spydercos, and none of them are junk either. I don't have any experience with this "compression lock." All my Spydercos are conventional lockbacks.

I don't own any linerlocks anymore and the only framelock I own is a Chris Reeve Sebenza, which is a substantially more expensive knife than any of yor choices above.
 
The Spyderco Military is nice, I don't like the para though, the handle is waaaay too big for the neutered blade.

The other ones scream "Mallninja" at me, just my $.02
 
I'd be concerned about the legal issue of what knife is acceptable to carry outside the US.

You can hire lawyers and possibly get yourself extracted from jail over a knife carry law, but the effort becomes exponentially more difficult if you're overseas away from your base of support.


The Para is an excellent knife.
 
My current favorite right now is the Benchmade mini Pikka II. If you look around you can find them for less than $30/ea. I'd get several. There are no issues with durability or quality (though sometimes the clips can be finicky) and at the price point they are almost disposable.

Depending on where you are going overseas, I would not recommend interacting with their legal system at all.
 
Thanks for the legal concerns. By overseas I meant Iraq, Afghanistan, and the Horn of Africa. :cool:
 
Jimmie,

Would this be carried on official gvt "travel"? If so, I wouldn't worry about the foreign legal issues. I also wouldn't worry about blade length or shape under those circumstances either.

BTW, AG doesn't have any junk made that has his name on it.
 
Would this be carried on official gvt "travel"? If so, I wouldn't worry about the foreign legal issues. I also wouldn't worry about blade length or shape under those circumstances either.
You are correct, sir. I spend about 180 days each year at Uncle Sam's various vacation resorts. This knife will be used as everything from care package and letter opener to chart cutter to worst-case survival knife. (I carry a larger fixed blade for worst-case, though).
 
Not really sure how it would meet your requirements but, if rust resistance is an a requirement you might check out the Salt Series from Spyderco. They don't rust, unlike the stainless steels on most knives today.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top