We don't have too many deer in Guntersville, but the roads by the state park are downright hazardous. Many years ago, a friend got tired of replacing grills and radiators on his dodge, so he bought a stout bumper. Last year, he managed to miss the deer with the bumper. I know he had two deer, including an 8 pointer, rip the dually fenders off of his truck. I happened on one incident where a large power truck hit several at one time. It was not pretty.
I guess I am for it. I don't deer hunt because I would rather duck hunt. If they did this, I could end duck season in January and still have at least a few trips to the woods to hunt deer. If we were allowed to bait deer, I have no doubt that the hogs would come to it too. It wouldn't matter to me, either one would be meat in the freezer.