An outstanding 1911

Status
Not open for further replies.

JesseJames

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2005
Messages
314
Location
CT, it's expensive here
Considering the plethora of choices of manufacturers, which is considered the cream of the crop?
I like the look of the 1911's with the extended barrel. And I am also left handed.
 
Para Ordnance / I carry the 745 Para LDA . Very accurate , smooth, reliable, But there are a few worthy 1911's on the market...

I trust my life with it
 
For production guns the current Colts are very well done. Better than anything I have seen in the same price range. Step up into semi-custom and custom and there are so many choices it isn't funny.
 
Cream of the crop.

The top dogs are Ed Brown, STI, Nighthawk, Les Bear, with manufacturers on this level you really do get a return for the coin you lay down.

Mass market pistols that are good include Colt, series one or post series two Kimbers, Smith and Wesson seems to be getting high marks for good pistols, Springfield "loaded" models are hugely popular with few problems it seems, and Para Ordnance. My own experience with Para was less than stellar at the start, but the pistol has really impressed me since.

Less expensive models that usually require some "fluff and buff" and don't look as nice are the Norinco (when you can find a used one), Rock Island Armory, Charles Daly (my carry gun, but NOT a pretty gun), and Auto-Ordnance (I think they got bought by Kahr, so quality may be improving).
 
Wow, thanks for the responses. Those STI guns are truly sick. I LOVE IT.
I got my eye on the Targetmaster and Rangemaster. Very reasonably priced for high-end pistols.
If you are going to spend the money; get what you want.
Thanks!
 
Cream of the Crop:

- Les Baer
- Wilson Combat
- Ed Brown
- Nighthawk
- Rock River Arms
- STI/SVI

ETA: Springfield Armory Professional model rivals heavily with the with all the semi-custom makers. :)
 
A gunsmith acquaintance swears by Caspian Arms, and likes those from Nighthawk as well. His is not a garage-shop operation either. He builds custom long arms and handguns for various folks with money, including those who write for national gun rags.

Personally, I have two Kimber .45s and a Colt Ace (.22). The Ace has a good day when it can feed a ten round magazine without jamming. The 5” Kimber, stainless, produced a few stovepipes during break in, nothing more serious, and then settled down.

I’ve got a Kimber CQB, three-inch barrel with the meltdown treatment. First day at the range it fired flawlessly with 180 and 165-grain Federal “Personal Defense” loads and 50 rounds of hardball. Took it home, cleaned it, and then started flicking the safety on and off, hammer back, while it was pointed in a safe direction of course. About 10-15 repetitions later, the slide safety simply snapped off under my thumb while flicking the lever down to the “off safe” position.

I’ve never had a gun that had fractured parts fall off of it, much less a $1,000 gun from a so-called factory custom shop—but that’s the only one of its type that I've owned. Anyway, Kimber sent out a replacement safety lever immediately when asked. But I’m going back to Ed Brown’s slide stops and external safety levers. Never thought a failure like that would happen to me, but what the . . .?

Also, save some money for a good trigger job after you break in the gun.
 
Why is it in post like these that Dan Wesson never gets mentioned?

From my limited experienced they make a fine pistol with some very good parts. I have heard very few complaints about them on the 1911 forums and what I have heard has been minor.
 
There is no answer to this question (and it's been asked many, many times).
People will argue forever for their favorite 1911 but the truth is, there are many excellent 1911's out there that could qualify as "cream of the crop". And that's a good thing!
 
Les Baer would be my suggestion. My Baer runs like a champ and is the most accurate 1911 I've ever owned, and I've owned Colt, Kimber, and SA. I sold all the others so I could buy a single Baer, and I couldn't be happier.

For a good deal on a Baer check out www.sportingarms.com They are good people and usually have a selection of Baers in stock.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top