First off, I want to reiterate that I really am tempted by one of these. I really am looking for reasons it's worth buying. I'm not trying to put it down. I want to want one.
Your point about unloading is a good one.
The point on the safety is good, though one can get rid of the silly safety on the Marlin altogether and just use the hammer.
It is lighter by half a pound, but that's mostly thanks to the chintzy plastic stock. It's also more than half a pound heavier than a Rossi '92 in .357.
Reliable feeding with multiple bullet shapes is good, though most people don't seem to have a problem LSWCs etc. in their lever guns. The big question I have that no one has answered yet is what is the max OAL that the magazine will hold. The other big advantage would be if there were spitzer bullets in the caliber that you couldn't use in a tube magazine, but I'm not really seeing any.
I would really like to see a head to head accuracy comparison some time. They're both short range guns that I personally would never put a scope on, so it would be interesting to see if there's a significant difference within the typical usage of this type of gun.
The rifle does load in seconds, provided you have purchased and pre-loaded multiple magazines.
Do you have a link for that NEGC sight? I'm not finding anything on it.
If a lever gun is double feeding rounds it is
broken.
I'm not one of those "Jack gun guys". I only have very limited use for a lever gun, and a pistol caliber carbine is about it. In any case, rather than rambling incoherently about follow up shot speeds, I'll just ask if you can do this with a 77/357:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nepNhDko5zs#t=23s
I'll be looking forward to the video, and have fun with the reload half way through.
Here, let's try a slight adjustment of your last paragraph:
Whether its a big bore ar cartridge or this Ruger, you guys cannot sit idly by and not bash on the leverguns that you perceive as a dying market. I'm not hating on either platform or the people who like them. You're getting more riled up than any of the lever gun guys in this thread