Forgive me Dr. Winslow, I clearly did not state my intended uses well enough. I guess, rather than low light I should say no light. We often hunt these hogs in dense terrain well after dark when they become active. We'll set up on a pig trail or pond and wait for activity, using surefire lights when they come into range. As I stated in an earlier post, this is generally at very close range. As you can imagine, anything outside the reach of the light is out of range. Occasionally we'll track them through heavy cover (grass, brush, woodland) where a magnified scope makes it difficult to acquire the hogs -- this from past trips where my 3x9-40 was just a little too much. As for punching paper, I should have said plinking, because while I will be on a range I won't be competing and will be tickled pink with pie pan sized groups at 100 yards. TEOTWAWKI? Now that I think of it...could be. Considering all this, I'm thinking the EOTech is a good fit. I guess in the worst case scenario I could use the EOTech a while and trade it, plus cash, for something more suitable.
Of the optics mentioned, the Leupold Prismatic really caught my eye though all are no doubt great choices.