Getting a factory-like blue is usually more a matter of polishing (or lack of it) than the type of blue used.
The major mistake most folks make is overpolishing. Most gunsmithing books tell you to get a mirror shine on the steel with the finest polishing compound available; that is OK if you want the gun to look like a Weatherby. But that takes time and costs money, and most factories do not do it.
Less polishing can simulate factory blue; in my experience, 600 grit will give a nice blue finish, while something about 800 will give the S&W blue. It is hard to tell someone how to do this. If you have access to a bluing tank, you can experiment with different pieces of scrap steel until you can determine just what you want.
I have no direct access to a bluing tank any more, but when I have a gun to do, I polish it and then tell the gunsmith to NOT touch it, only to degrease it.
Jim