Cleaning Tarnished Brass

Status
Not open for further replies.

Catpop

Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2012
Messages
2,705
Location
Eastern NC
I need to clean some badly tarnished (not dirty) brass and don’t want to spend hours doing it in my walnut shell vibrating cleaner.
Is there a safe,for brass, “wash” that will accomplish this?
Then I would rinse , dry and put into walnut shell vibrator to finish.
Any suggestions from experienced reloaders appreciated!
Thanks
 
Get some citric acid, can be found any where, I get mine from wal mart. Get some tap water good and hot, dissolve a table spoon or two of the citric acid in the hot water and dunk the brass in. You can literally watch it brighten up. It will also passivate the brass to keep it shiny much longer.
 
There are a lot of different solutions used. Most all contain Citric acid. Those of us that wet tumble with SS pins use citric acid (Lime-Shine), ArmorAll Wash & Wax or some other car cleaning product. Most of use deprime prior to cleaning so it will also clean the primer pocket. And the fact you want trap any cleaning solution. There is a commercial brass cleaner sold for sonic cleaners or just bucket cleaning. Works very well. Like with any of the acid cleaners it's best to neutralize after words or triple rinse.

If you see purple color your leaving them too long. If your seeing to leach out the zinc.
 
Spend hours in the vibratory tumbler or hours cleaning and drying with chemicals. Take your pick. I spend a lot more hand moving when I clean with chemicals than I do with the tumbler. Rotary tumblers are the best balance of cleaning speed AND hand moving. I set my vibratory tumbler to run overnight, screen the brass the next afternoon, and I'm done. For my ultrasonic, I'm busy for an hour straight changing my solution over and over, and then still wait a day to load as I wait for the brass to dry (just got a brass dryer, so that'll change). For the rotary tumbler, I dump it in and start it rolling in the morning, take it out at lunch, then it's dry and ready to load the next morning (again, brass dryer should have me ready that afternoon).

I use the "clean and shiny" method, slightly modified, from 6mmbr.com. I run 25min 50/50 white vinegar solution, rinse, 10min in Hornady One Shot solution, then 5min in hot water, then I rinse manually in cold water, 3x flushing, which takes about 5min in itself. Their method runs that last cold water rinse in the ULS cleaner, I do it manually so I can change the water.

So I handle my brass into the vibratory tumbler, then out into the screen roller, and a third time out of the screen, which does include some individual confirmation to remove all of the media. With the Rotary, I handle it into the tumbler then out to the drying rack. That's it. For the Ultrasonic, I handle it into the vinegar, rinse, into the One Shot, rinse, into the Hot water, then manual rinse, and then into the drying racks. LOTS of hand moving, lots of brass handling. But it comes out very clean - TOO clean in some ways - and it's all done in an hour, vs. 4 to 24.

I'd buy new brass before I spent time manually rubbing with a brillo pad or stirring a bucket of lemishine.
 
As a wet washer I dump the brass on a t shirt, bring the corners of the shirt up to make a handle like your gonna make a club. Shake it, roll it, bang it around. Might knock the media out of the pockets might not. I don't know because I've always been wet.
 
I use pure citric acid, get it on eBay. I mix about a gallon of hot water with an ounce of citric acid . Put shells in for 5 minutes, and they come out like new. The acid eats the tarnish off without any effort from you.
 
Citric acid is usually hiding in the canning section of Wal Mart or other supermarkets.

I would be tempted to take the easy cheap way, just throw it in your tumbler let it run ffor however log it takes, problem solved no $ spent except on juice to run the tumbler. (ok, I know that's not what you asked but it's the easy way:))
I wet tumble with pins, citric acid and Car was and wax.
Just for fun I have tossed in some really nasty range brass and in about an hour it looks good as new.
 
Thanks for all the great experience, suggestions, and links!
I changed out the walnut shells I had been running for last 10 years or so, rejuvenated the new lizard bedding with Nu car wax, and ran the 1-200 .30 carbine brass I had collected over the last 50 years for 10 hours. 90% came out looking new. I picked out the 10% that didn’t and will try the citric acid washing them.
That’s again!
 
Citric acid (used in home canning or Lemishine), Acetic acid (vinegar), Oxoleic acid (Barkeepers Friend) or any other weak acid can be used to remove tarnish from brass.
 
Tarnish, per se, is irrelevant.
Get dirt off the cases so the dies or inner workings of the firearm aren't scratched. Flash hole not plugged. But tarnish is superficial and really doesn't hurt anything.

Except: Tarnish can hide serious corrosion weakening the brass. One much check that.

I realize some simply want the loaded ammunition to look good. Fair enough. I'm somewhat proud of my ability in the matter. Having brass looking like it was salvaged from the Titanic or Blackbeard's flagship looks 'tacky'. Lots of ideas posted. I will add, if it comes down to hand cleaning, a dish scrubbing pad works well and doesn't harm the brass. Just takes a while.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top