Colt Trooper Mk III or Smith K22?

Status
Not open for further replies.

porterdog

Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2004
Messages
255
Location
Detroit (Rock City!)
Greetings!

I found a Trooper Mk III (in .22LR) locally, and of course there are plenty of various vintage K-22's on Gunbroker. A friend has a K22 and I've always enjoyed it, but I like the idea of a gun built for .357 being 'downchambered' for .22LR.

Can anyone that has experience with both give me a compare/contrast?

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
IMO, one's as good as the other....With that said, if that Colt were in good shape and priced right, I'd pick it up. A MK III .22LR is a highly sought after gun and is better than money in the bank as far as investments goes.
 
The Trooper Mark III's are built like a tank and may well be the strongest 22 revolver ever built. You will likely have many years shooting it without problems. Do not dry fire it.

Many people feel that the Trooper Mark III is too heavy in 22 caliber. I like the revolver myself and they are just as accurate as the M17's on average. My 6" Trooper Mark III is my favorite range revolver in 357 mag. Yes, I have them in 22 too.

I would buy the Colt today and get a M17 later. The Troopers were only made in 22 for a few years. Sales did not support continuing the revolver in that caliber since the Diamondback was still available retail. When Colt switched to the Mark V, there were clearly plans to offer one in 22 caliber based on the catalogs of the day. It never happened. The Diamondback continued production until 1986 as it was priced just a bit more than the Trooper Mark III in 22 and the Diamondback was heralded by the gun writers of the day along with the M17/M18.
 
Buy the Smith...... Please send me the contact info on the Trooper (so I can buy it). With that stated, depending on the cost I would buy the Trooper first, ie you don't see them around very often. Even better buy both.
 
The Trooper Mark III in 22 used to be the homeless stepchild of Colt. They made them and no so many bought them. For years after production stopped, you could find Trooper Mark III's NIB and priced to sell. I traded a 96%+ Diamondback (DB) for NIB one once as the gunshop. In hindsight, it may not have been the best deal based on future value alone, but I was happy and I got the DB for $285.

In recent years, there has been collector interest in them, especially in 22LR and 22WMR.
 
The Trooper Mark III in 22 used to be the homeless stepchild of Colt.

Not anymore ................one of the few semi affordable Colts available. Last Colt MK III .22 LR 6" Blue I saw new in box the seller had it at $785.00. Seemed to think he was offering a deal at that ......................
 
Sold before I could move. Those who pointed out the relative scarcity of the TIII seem to be correct- they're not generally available.

Anyone has a lead, I'd be interested.
 
22-rimfire,

There was a guy I worked with, was going to retire in a month, and wanted out from under some firearms he had. I ask about what he had, he opened his trunk and had a Colt Trooper and an M-1, he wanted $200 for the Colt and $275 for the M-1. I ask if he would/could wait until payday and I'd take the Colt off of his hands, I knew I should have gone by my Pop's that evening and borrowed the money. Next day it was sold, I've cried ever since, he said he'd only shot 100 rounds thru the Colt, beautiful 4", not a scratch!
 
uhhh.. like there is a wrong choice here ??
pretty much comes down to what you are willing to pay, but if you have the asking price, there ain't no wrong choice

(I do love k-frames, but if was dollar for dollar, I would soon own the Colt)
 
788Ham, I suspect most of us who are interested in collectable firearms or firearms in general have stories to tell about the one that got away. That was certainly a bargain and akin to stealing if that happened in the last year or so. But the seller sets the price and their circumstances clearly contribute to what the price is.

I have always tried to keep at least $1000 in cash at home in an envelope for "emergencies". These days this isn't much money. But we all do as best we can. Sounds like you had an emergency to me although my wife would not see it that way. :)

I try to learn from life's experiences and my history tells me to keep the fund stocked with cash for things that come up unexpectedly whether that be a firearm, auto repairs, or to grab because you have an unexpected road trip. The cash aspect has become less important with ATM machines and debit/check cards, but there are few things that make more impact than whipping out a stack of $100 bills.

My information may be a little dated, but $785 seems a bit high for a Trooper Mark III even in the box unless it has a nickel finish or is in 22WMR. They are typically priced about the same as a Model 17.

I recognized the Trooper and a few others as being sleepers in the collector market as much as 15 years ago. However 15 years ago, it was hard to choose a Mark III 22 when you could buy a Police Positive, Cobra, or the original Trooper for about the same cost. I suspect the same experience would apply to many and as a result, interest in the Trooper Mark III (22's mostly) has only really taken off in the last 5 years. However, for me, there have always been competing interests for dollars and as a result, I didn't act on my intuition as much as I should have.
 
I love Colts but have been looking for an older K22.

Were it me, I would buy the Trooper if the price is good. Trust me, if you decide against it will disappear like the proverbial fart in a whirlwind.

That said, I prefer the lighter gun, the Smith, for .22.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top