Considering getting into air gun replicas...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good evening,
Thanks for setting matters straight on beginning airgun velocity, Mr. Pete.. I do think that if you lose all of the CO2 propellant at two inches with a snubbie type pistol, the pellet or shot will travel less of a distance with less accuracy than it would in a longer barrel. I am also thinking that the projectile spends such a fraction of a moment within any handgun type length of barrel that accumulated friction has much less of an effect than the propellant being instantly lost to outside of the barrel volume of space at 2 inches versus 6 or 7.5 inches. Airguns should have the same set of physics apply as gunpowder weapons. Bullets fired from a conventional pistol start out at the same velocity just like projectiles from an airgun. Gunpowder gases expand in the barrel the same way that CO2 going from a liquid to a gas upon release do. Velocity and rate of expansion are different, of course. Unburned gunpowder in a short barreled powder weapon is the same as wasted CO2 in a short barreled airgun weapon. I have no experience with spring compressed airguns and so must stand aside at this point.. I will gladly stand corrected here on all points I have made if wrong.
regards!

EDIT: Having made such lofty statements, I thought it might behoove me to doublecheck ( I wanted to have ketchup ready in case I had to eat my words )
It turns out that I was wrong on longer barrel airguns being more accurate but
right on them having more velocity than shorter barreled airguns. The following is a write up on this subject by B.B. Pelletier, a well known and widely accepted fellow when it comes to airguns and what they will or will not do.
https://www.pyramydair.com/blog/2005/04/is-airgun-barrel-length-important/
I've got two identical CO2 air revolvers. One is a snubbie and the other is @5 1/2" barrel. The longer barreled gun shoots with more velocity than the snubbie. The manufacturer rates the fps at 50 higher for the longer barreled gun which I've witnessed in penetration of metal coffee cans. These are BB guns but it seems the same mechanics are at work as in regular powder burning firearms. I'm more accurate with the longer barreled gun, even off a rest, but that's probably got more to do with me than the accuracy of the gun itself.
 
I believe a lot depends on things like the calibration of the valve and TP as to whether a longer barrel will support more or less velocity.
 
Good morning,
That is too cool for school! Another one coming out is the Winchester replica that loads pellets in cartridges and ejects the carrier cartridge just as the powder version does. I haven't bought an air rifle in decades, these new replicas may tempt me to expand a little.
regards!
 
I have been spending some time at airgun forums since getting the velocity stuff wrong. As it turns out, what i wrote is still incorrect but maybe not as incorrect as I was thinking.
A pellet will accelerate for as long as the propulsive force pushing it down the barrel is greater than the forces that want to slow it down and stop it. As the pellet moves down the barrel the pressure of the gas behind it drops. With enough gas, the push continues until the pellet leaves the barrel.
I wonder if that is as true for my Feinwerkbau match pistol (mv 480fps +/-)as it would be for a pellet driven at 800/900 fps (that the gas charge continues to accelerate the pellet down that 10 inch barrel). There is certainly less gas involved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top