Hostile Amish
member
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2008
- Messages
- 522
Kimber Raptor II.
There's that old saying, "If you gotta say you are, you ain't." Look at a Para Ordnance advertisement for proof.
A top-drawer pistolsmith-artist, if you will, can articulate the difference between production work and his high grade custom work. If he couldn't, I fear he should have to quit our trade and do something else.
However, for my part it's not my place to make that distinction for others, nor at the expense of anyone else's efforts.
Having said that, I'm bemused almost to the point of offense to imagine anyone would compare the work of a Stan Chen to a Wilson, or a Baer, or another production pistol, however well done by the qualitative standards imposed by the laws of inverse economies of scale that prevent any such company from achieving more than some larger fraction of what a luminous, emerging talent like Stan can do far better and more efficiently on an individual, indeed CUSTOM, level.
The production shops are great at what they do: build lots of very good guns for a price. I've done that too, and it's hard, admirable work for which the better practitioners are to be respected.
However, you don't have to be Ayn Rand to see that in no way can the copy of a copy of an original piece embody the custom work, the ethos, that went into it's making. Confusing their products with high grade custom work does justice to neither in my opinion.
That's my take on it, with my obvious bias fully disclosed.