Denver cops kill again!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sindawe

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Messages
3,480
Location
Outside The People's Republic of Boulder, CO
DMF blazed the path with inflammatory Subject lines, so I'll follow and see where it goes.

Saw on recast of 2 News here in Denver, Denver PD reponded to a call (details not given). Seems a Denver resident was 'foaming at the mouth' from a drug overdose, reportedly cocaine. His family had call for an ambulance, while neighbors call the Police.

According to the report, the man who died had overdosed on cocaine, which he had done in in the past and abtained medical treatment for. He had charged/threatened Officers with a length of pipe. Officers responded with a Taser hit. The man resisted THREE hits from a Taser, even to the point of pulling the terminals out of his body and charging again. It took a total of FOUR shocks to get the man to surrender, at which point I presume EMS took over. The man later died.

News report reports that this is not the first time this man had done this, and the previous time he was informed that he has a "heart condition". News report then goes on to indicate that of the 80s some Taser 'related' deaths, roughtly 1/2 of those involved drugs and people with 'heart conditions'. Seeming to make a link (no scientific data presented) between those with a heart condition and death following being hit with a Taser.
------

K, my opinion on this. While I have been critical of Denver PD and their use of lethal force in the past, in this case Denver PD acted with a great deal of tolerance and consideration toward an individual who was, from the reports given, off his rocker and being aggresive. Four shocks were applied to the man in question before he surrendered/was taken under control. The man was armed with a blunt force weapon (pipe) and had acted in an aggresive and hostile manner toward the Police. It would have quite rational on the first charge to draw and fire on this man IMHO. I would have drawn and fired after the 2nd, but I'm not a trained LEO. Denver PD did not. They used their less than lethal devices to try and control the situation and keep people from being injured or killed. Unfortunatly, the man later died.

To my laymans eye, Denver PD acted in an appropriate and reasonable fashion, and then some. While lamentable that the man died, Denver PD bears no culpabilty in this case.

The mans adult step-daughter was shown on the Channel 2 news report stating that someone need to be held accountable for this man dying.

Yes, someone does. That someone was the man who died. According the to the data provided, HE is the one who injested cocaine, sufficent to prompt him to take leave of his senses and behaive in a manner such to merit is family calling for medical help and his neighbors to call the Police. HE was the one who injested cocaine, even though he had been informed that he had a heart condition, and had a problem with the substance in the past.

Though it may mean naught to the Officers on the scene and Denver PD in general: Good job folks, IMHO this was more than correct performance of your duties.

Side note: While reponding to this call, two other Denver PD patrol cars narrowely avoided a collision with each other. Sadly, in swerving, one of the police cars struck and damaged a private vehicle which was stopped at a stop sign. No injuries reported.

To Denver PD: Folks, we've seen you run into each other once on national TV. As entertaining as THAT was, please don't make a habit of it. It reflects poorly on the greater Denver area, cop cars are not cheap, and most importantly, Denver does want and need you guys on the street, not laidup in the hospital or filling a hole in the ground.

EDIT: Link to local news story: http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/3668640/detail.html
 
Last edited:
I'm thinkin' these TASER thingies ain't workin' out so well for LEOs overall...seems like a lot of news stories involve unsuccessful use of 'em. Either they fail do immobilize the BG or they kill'em anyway. Any stats?

TC
TFL Survivor
edit to add: I picture a linebacker-size LEO just running right through this guy, pipe or no. There's a DPS cop in the Pentagon force who would have little trouble smearing this dirtbag all over the pavement; "Man-Mountain" was invented for him :D
 
Tasers fall victim to the "ain't nothin' 100%" problem. Lets say you have a department armed with tasers and they juice people 1,000 times in a year. Of those 1,000 times, 4 of them are situations in which the BG fails to stop and the resulting Beatdown, Rodeo and Pigpile Triathalon is a thing of epic and newsworthy proportions. Also, one of those times the suspect- who had a heart condition from doing too much coke, too little Stairmaster, and having a 100% McDonalds diet, and had recently smoked a rock of crack that could be used to smash in a car window- ends up going DOA.

Guess what? Tasers don't work and they kill people. The media says so.

Nevermind the 9,996 cases where Little Billy Badd*** got juiced and then went to jail peacefully.



Mike
 
Link:

Man Fatally Stunned By Police Taser Identified
Police Say Man Frothing At Mouth, Swinging Pipe

POSTED: 6:07 am MDT August 20, 2004
UPDATED: 6:02 pm MDT August 20, 2004

DENVER -- Investigators are looking into why a man died an hour after police unsuccessfully used a Taser gun several times in an effort to restrain him.

Video


Family, Police Chief React To Taser Death





Officers said they were called to South Raleigh Street and West Tennessee Avenue around 7 p.m. Thursday on the report of a man walking in the middle of the street, frothing at the mouth and swinging a pipe. Police were told that he was overdosing on cocaine. Witnesses said that the man had been banging on, tampering with and breaking into cars parked on the street.

Two officers who responded to the scene said when they tried to talk to him, he became combative and charged at them. That's when they tried to subdue him with a baton and a Taser gun. Four attempts failed, as the man pulled the barbed Taser probes from his clothes and charged at the officers again and again, police said.

"This man continued to fight. Officers couldn't take him under control," said Denver police Detective Teresa Garcia.

Garcia said the four Taser charges didn't seem to have any effect and police were only able to take him to the ground and get him under control after other officers arrived at the scene.


KMGH
Police Chief Gerry Whitman defends the officers' use of a Taser gun.


The man was taken to Denver Health Medical Center, where he was pronounced dead about an hour later. He was identified Friday afternoon as Richard Kevin Karlo, 44, of Denver.

Karlo was a long-time boyfriend of a woman who lives in the neighborhood, according to the daughter of the woman. Jackie Long said she was talking to her mother during the incident.

"I was on the phone with her the whole time, listening to her cry and say they were going to kill him," Long told 7NEWS. "And my mom said, when she looked at him, she knew he was dead, right then."

Detectives did not say how many times officers struck the man with their night sticks.

Some neighbors confirmed that the man appeared difficult to subdue, and had brawled with the officers. They told reporters that officers beat Karlo several times with their hands, feet and even handcuffs.

Karlo's family believes that the officers overreacted to the situation.

Police Chief Gerry Whitman disagreed.

"They showed great restraint. They were overpowered by this person. They lost control of this person in hand-to-hand attempts to take him into custody, and then they resorted to the next level, which I thought was appropriate given the circumstances," said Whitman during a morning news conference.

Detectives are questioning the officers involved and several residents who witnessed the attack.

An autopsy will determine how Karlo died and whether he was under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Relatives confirmed that Karlo was using drugs and had a very weak heart.

Tasers fire two needle-like probes that deliver 50,000 volts of electricity, causing a suspect's muscles to lock up.

Last year, the city announced more crisis-intervention training for its police officers and deployment of more Tasers. Later, the police department modified its use-of-force policy to urge use of non-lethal means to subdue violent suspects.

Since 2001, at least 50 deaths across the country have been linked to Taser incidents. However, Taser International said its guns are not lethal, even for people with heart conditions. The company claims most of the deaths resulted from drug overdoses or other factors.
 
Ok, I'll flip the script on yah:

This sounds like it is probably a reasonable use of force. But, there's no way to know for sure that it was until the investigation is done.

See? I'll apply my caveats both ways. Do I think this will go down as 'good'? Yup...but its only because I know that the vast majority of cops are skilled and professional...theres no way to know for sure from the scant newsblurb offered here.

Mike
 
Mike,
I'm not taking issue with that. This guy obviously needed to go down hard. My point was that "unsuccessful" TASER use seems to be more and more common. Could be that TASERs themselves are being deployed more widely. I dunno the numbers.

TC
TFL Survivor
 
Darwin rules

It the BG had been home alone, it would have turned out as death by overdose, or accidental suicide. Whose fault is it if you die by by putting yourself in danger?

He relied on his family to try and save him (call 911/ ambulance). That was a selfish and stupid thing to do.

The PD showed remarkable restraint by tasering the armed and dangerous guy 3 additional times instead of shooting after the first failure, They subdued him so the medics could try and help him. He died anyway due to his own risky behavour.

Why dosent the newspaper report say:

"Family, Police and EMS go to great length to help man bent on self distruction" ?



Personal responsibility. :banghead:
 
Everything coming out of the boffin shops works 99% of the time -- until it hits the street.

Remember when OC first came out? We were told in reverent tones that pepper spray worked on 99% of the people tested.

Well, about a year after it got into the paws of the cops, the 99% success rate got downgraded to 90%.

Now it's what? Ten-twelve yars later? OC has an official stop rate of +/- 80%.

Same thing is going to happen to the Taser. In ten-twelve years it's going to turn out that the Taser has around an 80% stop rate.

*shrug*

LawDog
 
Ack.......:what:

Could it be......a positive thread (comments) about LEO'S on THR?????

;)

Taser use is up, but as LD pointed out.........nothing works 100%. I've see guys hit with OC who pretty much just laughed at the stuff. Thats when you know your going to have a long night
 
Thursday on the report of a man walking in the middle of the street, frothing at the mouth and swinging a pipe. Police were told that he was overdosing on cocaine. Witnesses said that the man had been banging on, tampering with and breaking into cars parked on the street.

Two officers who responded to the scene said when they tried to talk to him, he became combative and charged at them.

And they didn't shoot him? I'd say they showed great restraint.
 
Of course Tasers kill. They are regulated for models of the population as a while.

It's been my observation that most in the criminal class are not in the best physical condition and have many risk factors for early death--use of tobacco, illicit drugs, lack of exercise, alcohol, inter alia. As Cor says, no surprise that some would die from being Tased or running from the cops. (Had a guy do exactly this. Dropped over from a heart attack at 36 after running from cops after an OWI stop).
 
Leatherneck, sure, tasers are becoming more common, and I imagine will see even more use in the future.

So, think about what sort of dude is gonna be a taseree? A sober guy? Or somebody who's somewhere near drunk or is stoned on Chemical Goody?

So a taser won't kill a bad-heart guy; it won't kill a drunk or druggie. But some things work in combinations; ya gotta add things together to find problems. The body's version of binary nerve gas, I reckon.

It ain't "news" unless a Bad Thing happens. Remember the newsroom creed, "If it bleeds, it leads." Like Coronach said, you'll never hear about a quiet Zap-and-down.

:), Art
 
:D

I think these figures include cops who have OC'd by their partners in a scrap.
I doubt they do, but this does happen. The stuff splashes, and it gets freakin everywhere.

Been there, done that. Both sides of the OC cannister.

Mike ;)
 
Could be that TASERs themselves are being deployed more widely. I dunno the numbers.
What you see in the news represents a tiny fraction of Taser uses nationwide. According to TI, aproximately 5400 agencies are currently deploying the Taser, with 390 of them issuing to all officers on the street.

Denver, and other agencies up in the metro area are deploying the Taser every day, sometimes several times in a given shift. The many sucessful uses of the Taser just don't make the news. It's a great tool, and my experiance has been that 90% is about right. Which is, of course, no consolation to the folks in the last ten percent...
 
The coke head will get no sympathy from me . It was his decision to intoxicate himself with cocaine and it was his decision to attack the cops . When you break the law and attack the cops with a weapon IMO LEATHAL force would be an appropriate response from the cops . The fact that the cops used a taser on this degenerate instead of a double tap to the center of his mass to stop his attack on them shows me that they went out of thier way , putting thier own safety at risk to avoid killing him .
 
The girlfriend of the deceased said that he had had a "cocaine problem" for 20 years. Yep, he had a heart problem, it had been going about a billion miles an hour for two decades...No way does this get put on DPD.
 
I'm definately not a fan of the DPD, but as far as I can tell this is valid and justified.

I even think they were in the right last year when the "mentally handicapped" guy with the knife got shot. Agressive action with a knife can make you just as dead as aggressive action with any other weapon.

:uhoh:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top