Traditional (Recurve or Longbow) vs. Compound:
My thoughts after a fairly recent induction into the traditional world:
1. For *me*, traditional is a complete no-go, due to the numb fingers I get from shooting with fingers. I was using both a tab and a thick glove, and I still got permanent (until I quit shooting for several months) numbness in my fingers and along the outside of my palm. BUT FOR this fact, I loved traditional archery.
2. Traditionals don't have any set draw length. So they can be much much faster to
quickly shoot accurately, both because (a) you don't have to come to a full draw before releasing, and (b) you shoot instinctively, so no sights to line up. Albeit with the caveat that for ME to shoot instinctively with any accuracy, this necessitated a slow measured hold at full draw where I looked down the arrow for several seconds and made adjustments.
3. Traditional bows are far more aesthetically pleasing.
4. Traditional bows are typically lighter weight
5. Aside from 2, 3, and 4, compound bows have the advantage in every other category, most notably in (a) power and thus trajectory (b) ability to hold for a length of time at full draw due to letoff, and (c) accuracy, due to sights.
But traditional bows are a hoot, and better to learn the young'uns on.