DRT Percentage Poll

What percentage of deer that you have personally shot with a firearm were DRT?

  • 0-20%

    Votes: 26 25.5%
  • 21-40%

    Votes: 25 24.5%
  • 41-60%

    Votes: 21 20.6%
  • 61-80%

    Votes: 12 11.8%
  • 81-100%

    Votes: 18 17.6%

  • Total voters
    102
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
All I have to say is, if you can't find a deer within 30 yards, you shouldn't be hunting them.

One of the very first deer I ever killed was a decent sized doe at about 30 FEET when I pulled the trigger...........the bullet took her through the chest destroying the bottom half of her heart ( bummer really, heart is tasty!! ) and STILL ran an easy 100 yards.
 
Here in Texas, hunting a feeder that is never more than 100 yards away, from a box blind with a good rest, it is usually easy to wait for a good, broadside shoulder shot. These are usually freezer deer, so the lack of sport really doesn't bother me. The DRT percentage on these animals is much higher unless I get behind that shoulder, and then I will have some anxiety looking for an animal that may be a hundred or more paces from the shot. Three years ago, I lost one with a boiler room shot. First ever, still makes me sick. We found him three months later, and he was a nice, decent 100" deer. Just sickening. After that experience, shoulder shots for my tired eyes and general lack of shooting ability are going to be my primary objective.

Of course, there is occasionally a nice, well seasoned buck that refuses to approach the feeder, and manages to avoid a decent presentation. Those for me have more run-off potential from a less than perfect shot. "Less than perfect" in part because if the deer is nice enough, my heart is generally pounding hard enough to watch the crosshairs bounce within a three-foot range on my target animal.

35 years of hunting, and a really nice buck still tests my ability to control my shot. Maybe because in my neck of the woods, a really nice buck only comes along every three seasons or so. Pretty average to poor generally.
 
All I have to say is, if you can't find a deer within 30 yards, you shouldn't be hunting them.

Yeah, I know. Only a few people are good enough to hunt deer. :rolleyes:

And Texas does NOT have thicker , more impenetrable places than Florida. Maybe French Guiana or Cameroon does but not Texas.

Who said it did and why is the comparison an issue. It doesn't matter where has more. If you can't get through it or have trouble finding your critter in it where you are, then it is a problem regardless of where you are.
 
And Texas does NOT have thicker , more impenetrable places than Florida. Maybe French Guiana or Cameroon does but not Texas.

I've been to Florida once, and did not wander far from the beach to test the thicket comparison. All I can say is this; on my place there are adlers and briars so thick that if a wounded deer managed to find a way into one, they would find themselves donated to the coyote preservation society.
 
What Patocazador said wasn't referring to how far the deer was from you when you pulled the trigger nor was it a comment on how far a deer runs in relation to your ability.

He meant that if the deer runs only 30 yards after the shot and you can't find the deer you shouldn't be hunting them.

And he's right for 95% of situations.
 
And Texas does NOT have thicker , more impenetrable places than Florida. Maybe French Guiana or Cameroon does but not Texas

Perhaps not, but it is at LEAST the equal (many places). Of more importance...is WHAT that 'impenetrable' place consists of.

If you are trying to walk through an area choked with palmetto and the associated brush versus our Green Briar, Black Berry, Cactus, Whitebrush and more thorny bushes than we have room to list here, then it does make a difference. ;)
 
My last doe I took out the heart and lungs at 70 yds, she ran about 150. Almost lost her because she got on the other side of a tree line, after 20 yds there was no blood. She'd been eating so well on the corn and beans, the fat plugged the entry and exit holes. Tasted almost more like corn fed beef than venison.
 
I voted 21-40 % . They were neck shots, from 25 yd to 100 , with 22 hornet,30-30,243,7mm08,308,all were DRT dead right there !
 
Perhaps not, but it is at LEAST the equal (many places). Of more importance...is WHAT that 'impenetrable' place consists of.

If you are trying to walk through an area choked with palmetto and the associated brush versus our Green Briar, Black Berry, Cactus, Whitebrush and more thorny bushes than we have room to list here, then it does make a difference.

I was once in a hunting club that had a 13000 acre lease near Pumpville in west Texas west of the Pecos. I always took 3 spare tires with me, usually wound up using at least one or two of 'em in a week's hunting. You just don't go plowing through stuff with stickers like that. Boy, do I have some thorn stories! :D

Texas is a big place, more diverse in vegetation than Florida.
 
I'd say about 20% have DRT. On average most of mine get a 20 yard jog in before taking a nap.
 
I shot a buck last year and he did a twisting front flip and was dead. when I dressed him out, his heart had exploded. I just found bits and pieces of it....so is that a DRT?
 
So far, I have never had a deer or an elk do anything but drop in their tracks. I have only taken main vital area shots, with the exception of one deer I shot in the spine, just above the vitals, there was a bush in the way and I did not want the shot deflected. Total; two deer, one antelope with a .243Win, two deer with a 30-06, three deer, two antelope (not drt), two elk with a .270Win.

Both elk were with a 270, a three year old cow I shot in the vitals; the bullet smashed a rib, clipped the heart, both lungs, deflected up, cut the spine and exited through a second rib. She was about 80yds. I helped anchor a young, rag horn, bull that had three grazing hits from a 30-06: it was at a dead run, left to right, at 50yds off hand. It tumbled head first about three times, landing on its back with a hole through the heart and a 270 bullet neatly caught in the skin on the other side.

I have shot, when young and naive, two antelope with a rifle that was not sighted in properly. One hit the brisket and it ran 30yds, the other destroyed a backstrap (frontal shot) it ran about 5yds and turned broad side to take one high and to the right in the spine.
 
I must be doing something wrong. I have shot many big game animals in the boiler room and to the best of my recollection, none of them dropped in their tracks. I have shot a few in the head or neck (before I knew better) and of course al of them dropped in their tracks.
 
I shot a buck last year and he did a twisting front flip and was dead. when I dressed him out, his heart had exploded. I just found bits and pieces of it....so is that a DRT?

I will officially (for this poll anyway) call that DRT! I had a deer do kind of a half front flip once when I shot. It hit ground and was still... for a second. My celebration was just beginning when it got up and ran off!!! I spent about 8 hours over two days looking for that deer and never found it.
 
I must be doing something wrong. I have shot many big game animals in the boiler room and to the best of my recollection, none of them dropped in their tracks. I have shot a few in the head or neck (before I knew better) and of course al of them dropped in their tracks.

Given the poll results, I think you are pretty normal. Those that shoot for lungs heart seem to expect their deer to go a little ways. I know I do! In my 30ish deer the only ones I've had drop and die right there were a couple front shoulder hits and a couple where the slug fragments or bone fragments damaged the spine. Shotgun slugs or muzzleloader projectiles are what my experiences are based on.
 
I shoot for the neck up they drt right there

Until you hit one in the neck that doesn't strike bone or jugular.
Or you shoot one in the head and it misses by mere inches and you just blow the lower part of it's jaw off.

Then they run away leaving no blood trail and slowly starve to death or die at the hands of predators.

The only way I would take a neck shot is with a fast, quickly expanding bullet like a SGK BTHP or a ballistic tip. Controlled expansion bullets like Core Lokts, no way.

I helped a neighbor look for a wounded deer on my back property that he shot in the head. Except it landed at the jaw. We saw the deer running with it's lower jaw hanging by a flap of skin.

Head shots aren't always DRT and are rarely the best shot to take.
 
I voted '81-100%', but then I realized that DRT didn't mean "Dead 'Round Thursday". Not sure what to do now.
 
Head shots aren't always DRT

People fail to understand this for self defense as well. Large portions of the head are non-CNS structures that can be damages without stopping the critter.

and are rarely the best shot to take.

That is a matter of opinion. I see people mess up heart/lung shots as well, leaving the deer to suffer and quite possibly die at the hands of predators as well. There are all sorts of stories of messed up shots on various parts of animals that can be used to argue against making a shot on that area. It is always easiest to call a bad shot AFTER the shot is made, LOL.
 
morcey2 said:
I voted '81-100%', but then I realized that DRT didn't mean "Dead 'Round Thursday". Not sure what to do now.

Hahaha! That made my night!
 
Moray made the best post, lol. You know I never thought to count steps after I shot a deer. I am happy to see one drop in sight.
 
That is a matter of opinion. I see people mess up heart/lung shots as well, leaving the deer to suffer and quite possibly die at the hands of predators as well.

That's true.
I just go by the fact that there's a larger margin of error for a lung shot.
But I've certainly saw my share of gut-shot deer too. I've had folks in the hunting lease ask for help tracking a wounded animal and saw the tell tale green bile and digestive matter in the bloodtrail and knew that chances of recovering the animal were slim.

So I don't disagree with you at all.
Personally I wouldn't take a head shot unless the range was extremely close.
 
Shot a 150 lb buck on a sidehill.I hit a round bone in the shoulder area.A piece of bone about 1 inch long entered the chest.He rolled down the hill kicking.He kicked for minutes but could not get up.Down right there,yes.Dead right there,no.
 
I voted 20-40. Last year was a good year for DRT for me. I had took a small buck while it was pointed away from me but with its head turned back looking at me. I took a neck shot and he was dead when he hit the ground. I shot a doe at about 100 yards through the lungs and she dropped in her tracks. I shot a cow elk at about 225 yards through the neck and she too was dead immediately. The only exception last year was a bear that I shot in the liver that ran into some brush, but even he wasn't ever out of sight.

Most years I'm not that lucky, but I've never had to track an animal for more than a few hundred yards. Knock on wood...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top