Had to get both of them...and glad I did.
So, just to update anyone who cares...
I took some good advice from the folks here on the boards and bought both rifles. I still have the old Ishapore too, just for use as a restoration project/hobby on those rainy days. I'll probably sell the Ishapore the first chance I get, though, as it is the only gun in my collection that just doesn't quite fit. Oh well, I'm happy with the other two, that's for sure. Thanks to all who responded. Here are 2 pics of the newest additions to a crowded gun safe.