Flashpoint said:
Seen some BSG for the first time tonight. I feel asleep watching "John Doe" and woke up to BSG. I just assumed there was something in the plot that accounted for the old guns being used on a space ship
So really, what's up with that? At least on SG-1 it's suppose to be present day US military.
The new Galactica also uses old military hardened phones on the ship. I believe the idea was that the ship itself was outmoded and about to retire, sort of like an Iowa-class battleship...but it turned out to be sturdier than the newer ones.
I kind of like the allusions, myself. The "new" Vipers have a cockpit like a Stealth, and the "pulled from the museum" ones have a cockpit like a Vietnam-era fighter.
Nice touch. That, and Star Trek made the mistake of arming people with wimpy dustbusters. I like the fact that they realize that people who fight are going to want a gun that fits in the human hand for good balance (hence the shape of a gun!), is sturdy, no-nonsense, and that they can field-strip and maintain. So I'd call, in a fiction sense, the design of the guns as a sort of convergent evolution. That basically any race just like ours would end up with hand weapons that looked and operated a lot like our pistols and rifles, because form follows function.
Farscape, once, did another nice little bit. A human alien warrior, trained since birth, used to "energy weapons", simply studied and then was able to use what looked like an AR here without problems, no stupid "your weapons are strange" silliness, she just had to figure out the operation.