OP wants to load 8 calibers.
Not including scale, case trimmer and other misc stuff
So roughly 8 sets of dies @ $40 ea (you can spend more on dies, but to keep it simple lets call it 40) =$320 (shell holder come with Lee dies, so you wouldn't need shell holders)
Lee LCT ~$100
Turrets 8 *$15 = $120
So $540
I will assume $40 a set for dies for the Dillon and LNL as well.
I am also not adding in cost for PTXs for the LNL, or bases for the measure, don't know what you would need to do the same on the Dillon but I would venture it would add $100-$200 to the costs for the progressives.
(progressives do come in green and other colors just doing Red and Blue
)
I would think the cost of caliber conversion for a Dillon for 8 calibers would be quite a bit more
Shell plates for a Dillon are what about $35 ea? 8*$35 =$280
Toolheads for the Dillon are about the same $35 ea? So another $280
So $560 to change on the Dillon vs $120 for the Lee.
Dillon 550 about $480 so total $480+$560+$320 = ~$1360
(manual index 550, 4 stations, guessing at least $300 more for a 5 station auto index 650)
You would need shell plates and bushings for a LNL as well so
LNL Shell plates 8@$35 ea = $280
Bushings 3 for $12 so 8*$12 =$96 lets call it $100
So $380 for caliber conversions for a LNL, a little cheaper than the Dillon but still lots more than for the LCT
Hornady LNL about $400 so total $400+$380+$320 = ~$1100
So we have
Turret $540
Dillon 550 $1360 (+powder measure stuff so add $100-200)
Hornady LNL $1100 (+powder measure stuff so add $100-200)
so either of those progressive options are twice as much money.
(not saying these are exact numbers, but they should be close)
Nothing wrong with Dillons (I happen to own an LNL and a Lee turret) but the cost to go with a progressive vs the turret is quite large.
OP said 150 rnds of .44 a week + small QTYs of others maybe more .38/.357, so given the QTY required I would not recommend a progressive.
It was mentioned the OP could save before buying the press, the OP could but the LCT save and add a progressive later for higher volume calibers.
It also sounds like the OPs friend has both a LCT and a Dillon so he has had a chance to use both.
I would say buy the LCT to start.
Don't load .44, but do load .357, 9mm and .45 (and others)
Good cost savings on all of the above,
not as much on 9mm and .45 but quite a bit on .357 I would imagine on .44 you would save quite a bit as well.. (assuming you don't shoot up the savings
)
so why are you looking at LEE yes Lee makes stuff that works but so does harbor freight now I'm not bashing lee but if i had $400. to spend on Reloading equipment I would be looking for better quality even if you buy used
????
Ok so if we are not bashing Lee, why are just casting all Lee and Harbor Freight products in as undesirable?
.
I love this line of thinking, I had one Chevy-Ford-Dodge-Honda-BMW (fill in blank) that was bad so everything they make must be bad, hmm seem to remember something about that from Logic 101.
I have loaded probably 20000 rounds on my old inexpensive 3 hole Lee "Deluxe" AL turret and it still seems to work fine.
Press cost roughly .003 per round (60/20000 only the press not other stuff)
I think that's pretty good value for the same cost as 2 steak dinners, 4 pizzas, or 7 1/4 with cheese meals.
Curious what do you feel is wrong with the quality of a LCT or other Lee press?
Specific examples would be helpful and informative if you have some.