My experience goes kinda like this: If you think it's the right size, sometimes it's too big. If you think it's the right weight, sometimes it weighs too much. When you think you've found the right holster, you need to try 10 more to find the REALLY right holster. It never ends. The only thing consistent in what I've been carrying is the LCP because sometimes that's the only thing that fits. Other than that I've gone through an XD45, Glock 26, FNP9, 5" 1911, M&P 9 and a few others. I do like the 1911 because it's slim but it's also pretty heavy.