Henry Big Boy, .357/.38

Status
Not open for further replies.

GP100Wii

Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2011
Messages
73
I was going to get a Marlin 1894C, but with so many complaints (marlinowners.com is full of them!) about poor products since the Remington takeover.... I don't really want to drop money on a poor gun.

So, I guess I'll have to drop *more* money on a good gun! I want a .357/.38 lever action or bolt action, so looks like Henry's Big Boy is the one.

Any experience with these, good or bad? How accurate? Durable?

What's it like to scope one of them?:cool:
 
I own the BB in .44. Recoil on .357 should be negligible. I love mine. And it was super accurate right out of the box with the marble buckhorn sights. I will say that the octagonal bbl makes the front end a tad heavy. Smooth action though.
 
It's not the big boy, but I've got the .22. The first one came with a bent barrel. 2' wide at 15 yds. Henry replaced it straight away and were easy to deal with. The new one has been fine.

Have you considered the Rossi? they're pretty good and clean up nicely.
 
Personally I'd hunt around for a good used Marlin. (if you can hold out). While I don't have a .357 I do have a few older, used, 30-30's and and a 39. Mine are rock solid.
 
All reports I've seen about Henry customer service have been excellent. On that accout only I feel that it would be a good way to go for a lever gun. The only thing that puts me off about them is the lack of the side loading gate.

The Rossi '92 clone that I got for my cowboy action shooting handled .357's just fine as long as I didn't rack the lever super fast. Much of my slicking up of the gun since first shooting it has been related to making it work with .38 length cartridges. But the Rossi is inexpensive enough that you could buy one and have a local smith that does cowboy guns a lot slick it up for a little more. The final result would be a superb gun.... unless you want to mount a scope to it or set it up for a receiver mounted peep sight. Then it wouldn't be the best choice.
 
I'd look for a used Marlin or one of the 1892 replicas. IMHO, the Big Boy is too much money for too little quality and is about 2lbs heavier than it should be.
 
GP100Wii....

I own 4 Henry Rifles....H006M (Big Boy .357), H009 (30-30), H001 (.22) and H001T (.22) so while I don't post here often, I feel qualified to address your post.

The H006M is a fabulous gun. I've had one for 2 1/2 years and it is my favorite centerfire rifle bar none. It is the one centerfire that goes with me to the range every single time I go. Its a blast to shoot. .357 rounds are comparatively inexpensive by centerfire standards. With the Marbles tang sight I installed I can easily hold 2 MOA from a seated position....not from a bench. I'm a hunter not a paper puncher, so I practice from hunting positions not from a bench. This is also my favorite woods deer rifle. Ballistics not withstanding, it takes deer with more authority than my 30-30. 158 grain JSP reliably gives me through and through penetration and leaves a blood trail a blind man could follow in the dark.

As to accuracy.....As I said, I don't shoot from a bench. I shoot from hunting positions and I shoot with irons. And at 54 and wearing glasses, my eyes aren't the best. As you know, most rifles are capable of more accuracy than their owners. From a bench, with a scope, good ammo and a good triggerman behind it, I am pretty confident my rifle could shoot MOA or very close to it.

Durability.....I bought mine used with a "claimed" less than 200 rounds through it. In 2 1/2 years I have put over 2500 rounds through it. No FTF. No FTE. No problems.

Let me also point out that ALL Henry Rifles come with a NO BS lifetime warranty....whether you are the original owner or the 10th owner. Yes....That means that if you buy one used you still get the lifetime warranty. Sounds crazy doesn't it? If you have any doubts, send Anthony Imperato (President of Henry Repeating Arms) an email.... [email protected] and ask him. He'll tell you so himself. In writing. Their customer service is also unsurpassed in the firearms industry. When one of their guns does have a problem they repair or replace them at no charge to the owner...usually in under 4 weeks from the time the gun is shipped by the owner. HRA even pays for the shipping in both directions.

My other Henry Rifles (all bought new) have been equally reliable. I don't shoot the 30-30 much. No reason to since I have the .357. The .22s I have long since lost track of how many rounds I have put through them. I can shoot them in the back yard so I shoot the bejeepers out of them. The only problem I've had with the .22s is that they will not feed properly if I turn the rifle on its side when I work the lever. They want to be held properly when the action is worked.

Mounting a scope....My .357 is a '07 gun. Requires the purchase of a cantilever scope mount to mount a scope. I haven't used one, but others I have talked to say they are sturdy and reliable. No need to worry about changing POI.

A nice side benefit......These guns are 100% Made in the USA.

OK....Now the one "bad" thing about the Big Boy. They are heavy. Weight is approximately 8.68 lbs. That weight helps with keeping the gun steady for offhand shots (at least for me) and is great for hunting from a stand. On the other hand, if you "still hunt" and will be pussyfooting through the woods all day with the gun "at the ready" it will quickly seem VERY heavy....especially if you mount a scope on it.

On the other hand, that same weight means their is little or no recoil even shooting near max reloads.

These are excellent guns made by a fine company that stands behind their products like no other.

Best.....2few
 
I was going to get a Marlin 1894C, but with so many complaints (marlinowners.com is full of them!) about poor products since the Remington takeover.... I don't really want to drop money on a poor gun.

In Marlin's defense, I'll have to say that if you buy new and fix the lever's edge that is the root cause of the dreaded Marlin jam, you'll probably be fine. Mine's a pre-Remington ('07) gun and fortunately I came across the fix before I started shooting it. It's been trouble-free ever since and one of my all-time favourite leverguns.

No first hand experience of HBB, other than handling one at a gun shop. IMO it's a bit heavy, which can be a good or bad thing, depending on what you're going to use it for. Nice build quality, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top