Depends. BHP's are a little heavier.
I use BHP's in .40 S&W for my carry guns, a Practical and two standard MKIII's and they are fine combat weapons. I see slightly used standard models for around $400 here in Houston, Gander Mountain has new Practicals for $599.
I have two polymer frame pistols, a EAA Witness PS and a fairly new Springfield XD9 Tactical. The Witness is my bedside gun and the XD9 is being used for IDPA. Witness had a better trigger, XD9 has better sights. Actually I should say the XD9 trigger is just different, just took a few weeks to get used to. The Witness is about 8-9 years old and has never had a problem of any sort, probably be time to change some springs out soon though. The XD9 has been a good pistol so far, reasonable accuracy, good ergonomics for me, and smooth shooting with the 5" barrell.