High Noon Topless or Slide Guard?

[Digex2]

I'm interested in these two holsters for OWB carry and I'm trying to decide which one will work better for me. The questions I have are:

1) Will the Topless be more concealable and comfortable enough compared to the extra leather and comfort of the Slide Guard?

2) If I go with the Topless, will my Glock have a tendency to dig into my side?

 

[Flashpoint]

Here is a link the Highnoon's product line. I would go with the Slide Guard, I have one that I carry my p239 in and without the extra leather it would dig into my side. The Topless would not be any more concealable, it essentially the same pattern as the SlideGuard, just without the extra guard.

 

[rblack]

I have the topless for a commander and while it is a very nice holster, I wish I had gotten the slide guard.